Share this project


Share this project

The Settlers of Catan board we've all been waiting for. Portable, affordable, and true to Catan craftsmanship.
The Settlers of Catan board we've all been waiting for. Portable, affordable, and true to Catan craftsmanship.
The Settlers of Catan board we've all been waiting for. Portable, affordable, and true to Catan craftsmanship.
5,331 backers pledged $361,030 to help bring this project to life.

Use this space to cheer the creator along, ask questions, and talk to your fellow backers. Please remember to be respectful and considerate. Thanks!

    1. Missing avatar

      James M on November 22

      Does anyone live anywhere near San Luis Obispo? If so, have you tried swinging by their office and just asking for your RCH and/or bag? According to the CA Sec of State, they are at:

      SAN LUIS OBISPO CA 93401

    2. Josh Helton on November 10

      Time for the monthly "pesky backer" tweet asking @trammel for an update on my Seafarers board.

    3. Josh Helton on November 8

      Breaking News: Unexpected expenses have caused RCH to not ship until Q1 2017. Next update in late December.

    4. Michael Sprague
      on November 3

      I thought I'd check in and see if Mr Trammel might have left a little excuse here.... Everyone knows thieves like to visit the scene of their crimes.... I did notice he last logged in on 10/27.....

    5. Josh Helton on October 28

      Line, not like.

    6. Josh Helton on October 28

      I wonder how long he expects us to buy the "unexpected expenses" like that he's been using for the better part of a year now.

    7. Jimmy Hudson on October 25

      Facebook just reminded me that four years ago I was asking all my friends to back this project so we could hit $200,000 and unlock resource card holders.

    8. Josh Helton on October 5

      Here's an idea: ship the RCH, then start selling them along with the boards to raise money faster to make seafarers boards.

    9. Andy Roth on October 4

      All these resource cards... nothing to hold them.

    10. Missing avatar

      Joan on October 3

      I would REALLY like to see an audit of where, when, and how much money from this project (and the other one) has been spent. He gets money and then "unforeseen circumstances" eat it up. Sounds like he's wasting the money on something.

    11. Missing avatar

      Blair on October 3

      My Credit card got charged but no RCH... guess I have to cancel that charge.

    12. Michael Sprague
      on October 3

      There is a difference between being patient, and having enough of the lies.... Anyone who thinks he's actually going to honor anything is just enabling his entitled behavior - and that's what keeps him from responding, he doesn't feel the need to be held accountable.

    13. Josh Helton on October 2

      @Steve - Update #92, October 26, 2015. He's been claiming for the past year that RCH will be shipping any day now. Words mean nothing. Actions do. Until there are any concrete actions taken, I will believe him just as much as I did a year ago. Holding a man accountable for what he says, and calling him out when he is lying is not whining. We knew what we were getting ourselves into, but he had to as well; especially after telling us lies time and again for a year to pacify us.

    14. Eric Wood on October 2

      When will original backers get their addon RCH's? I pledged for a pari of those over 3.5 years ago.

    15. Steve Creech on October 2

      I too have been waiting from the beginning. I did receive the 3-4 player blue plastic board but am waiting for the 5-6 player and the RCHs. Every single one of us knew the risks of backing a Kickstarter. If you weren't willing to be patient and accept what that risk meant then you shouldn't have been a backer. It's that simple. Whining about it and making baseless threats accomplishes nothing. If you can't at least act like adults here, then do the rest of us a favor and shut up. Your toxicity and negativity is exactly why Bill Trammel no longer reads these comments.

    16. Ted Rathkopf on September 29

      I backed this for 2 boards + RCHs. One for me, and one for a friend. The friend has moved since I backed this. TWICE. Still no RCH.

    17. Josh Helton on September 29

      Okay, so September 25th has come and went, maybe by October 25th we'll get an update.

    18. Michael Sprague
      on September 27

      No, @Josh - it'll be more like:
      I really planned on sending the RCH's out this month, but you guys haven't bought enough of my overstocked items, that I over-extended myself beyond actual demand for, and so I can't afford to ship them (loose paraphrase, of course)

      Or (most likely) the next update will be a no-details update on the sale of the company, because he won't be allowed to disclose the actual details, for legal reasons, but he knows we'll understand.

    19. Josh Helton on September 21

      Well, only 4 more days until his two month update telling us the RCHs will be sent out starting October 1. He really means it this time guys, he's super serial.

    20. Christopher Green on September 13

      @Josh Nothing you said is wrong. So say that instead of hyperbolic statements like, "It's unlikely he'll ever do a single damn thing he says." Comments like that serve no purpose and only add to the toxicity runs rampant here.

    21. Missing avatar

      Jeff on September 13

      Don't forget, the RCHs have been FINISHED since LAST February. As in 19 months ago! And he supposedly began shipping them LAST July. I've yet to hear of a single person receiving a RCH holder 14 months later! It's simply unbelievable!

    22. Josh Helton on September 12

      @Christopher - We've not been getting updates on this KS though, we've gotten plenty on the other one. I don't care about the bags or dice towers. He's been saying since May that the RCH will be shipped out soon (just wait ten days longer!) but he never follows through with it. Funding shortfalls don't just happen overnight, he had to be aware of the budget when writing the update and thus didn't intend to ship them at that time. Most recently he told us that they would start shipping on August 1st. This obviously hasn't happened, yet we've heard nothing from him.

    23. Christopher Green on September 12

      Yes, this campaign is taking a long time. Yes, this campaign has seen more downs than ups. And yet, we still receive an update every one to two months, usually with pictures ands video. It is clear things are moving forward, albeit, not as fast as many people (myself included) would like. While that can be both discouraging and disappointing, it is clear that progress is being made, and to say otherwise is foolhardy.

    24. shellynel
      on September 12

      My current theory is that he posted those updates to placate the masses and make things look like they are moving along while he negotiated to sell his 'smoothly operating' company.

    25. Michael Sprague
      on September 11

      @david - because instead of honoring his word (which he hasn't done since the original boards went out) he apparently was out trying to sell his company - he doesn't give a single care to any of his backers, his ongoing negligence and lies have demonstrated this time and time, again.

    26. David Siskin
      on September 11

      Six weeks later...nothing!

    27. David Siskin
      on September 11

      From July 25...

      When will you ship Resource Card Holders (RCHs)?

      Our previous update stated that backers of the 2012 Kickstarter who already received a standard board, walnut board or aluminum board and who are also owed one or more RCHs and no other rewards would receive a final shipment in June 2016. Unfortunately, unplanned financial constraints made it impossible to fulfill this commitment. We now plan to ship RCHs to affected backers starting August 1, 2016.

    28. Michael Sprague
      on September 8

      @josh - I fell ya.... Personally, I gave up giving any benefit of doubt over a year ago.....

    29. Josh Helton on September 7

      @Michael - It's unlikely he'll ever do a single damn thing he says, but I was trying to give him the benefit of the doubt. Six days (time between last update and August 1) is apparently more than enough time to decide he won't be sending out RCH to anybody, if he ever intended to in the first place.

    30. Michael Sprague
      on September 7

      @josh - it is unlikely that they are being mailed out - not with the sale of the "company"

      And depending on who buys it, they may not even fulfill them.... They'd be under no obligation.

    31. Josh Helton on September 3

      A month out, has anybody got the RCH yet?

    32. Michael Sprague
      on August 30

      Has anyone heard who the scam artist is selling the "company" to?

    33. Josh Helton on August 23

      Screenshotting for @Jeff:

      Bill, care to weigh in on the future of the KS rewards and what this means for us backers?

    34. Josh Helton on August 23

      Not that Bill does in the first place, but it would be nice to have SOMEBODY that gives a shit...

    35. Josh Helton on August 23

      And will the purchasers of the company give two shits about fulfilling KS rewards.

    36. Donatos Aphael on August 23

      Now the question in my mind is : Who is he selling the company to ?

    37. Missing avatar

      Jeff on August 22

      Nope, and we may never!

      8/16 on Twitter
      "In the process of selling previous company, and I want to take a break from startup life. 9 to 5 sounds A-OK right now"

    38. Josh Helton on August 17

      Just curious, has anybody received their RCH since they were supposed to start shipping on 8/1?

    39. Sean Stiff on August 9

      It's this and one other that I have waited just as long for that are like 2 of my three Kickstarter experiences. These two experiences are why I don't support Kickstarter projects any longer.

    40. Josh Helton on July 26

      @Kyle I don't even play the game that often anymore. We always play seafarers, so I can with play without that and use my board, or not use the board and play how I want.

    41. Missing avatar

      Kyle Mays on July 26

      At this point, I would rather have the catan bag than the rchs and seafarers board. I don't play the game enough anymore with the expansion.

    42. Michael Sprague
      on July 25

      You all realize he isn't actually going to ship anything... His last update gave him a year to do nothing, and not have to answer to anything.... The RCH's have been "ready to ship" for over a year, already... What makes you think he'd care enough to send them now?

    43. Jimmy Hudson on July 11

      Any news on the RCHs? I look forward to hearing from you! Thanks.

    44. Missing avatar

      Travis Mellema on July 11

      The last update from May 25th stated that they would ship RCH's June 3rd. Just wondering if anyone received a shipping confirmation as I have not and it's been a month. Just curious.

    45. Josh Helton on June 27

      It's been a month. Exactly how often were you planning on these regular updates to be given?

    46. Michael Sprague
      on June 10

      @brad - the problem is he has, effectively, run and hidden.... he posts occasional vague posts, and even throws in a backhanded apology, once in awhile.... but hasn't actually produced a thing in years, just keeps posting pics of things we've already seen... it's nothing but smoke and mirrors, Ponzi scheme at best....

    47. Missing avatar

      Brad Andrews
      on June 9

      I do hope you have more to sell to make enough to take care of all these orders Bill. Your site is very light on things it is selling. Make some more wooden boards for example, those have been sold out for some time. The base plastic boards are nice, but the market for them is likely quite limited.

    48. Missing avatar

      Brad Andrews
      on June 9

      Many of you need to grow up a bit. Life happens. All KS campaigns don't wildly succeed. I will be glad to get anything out of this. Legal means would end up meaning you would get pennies on the dollar for what you spent, if you got anything at all. Lawyers are expensive.

      He has a tough thing to dig out of, but at least he didn't run away and hide as some do for failed KS campaigns.

    49. Missing avatar

      Alan Clift on May 31, 2016

      So what is the best approach for taking legal action?

      All I got from asking Kickstarter is terms of use. 'You agree that any action at law or in equity arising out of or relating to these Terms, or your use or non-use of Kickstarter, shall be filed only in the state or federal courts located in New York County in the State of New York, and you hereby consent and submit to the personal jurisdiction of these courts for the purposes of litigating any such action.'

      Unfortunately, while Kickstarter made it easy to get into this situation. They offer nothing of help for us backers now.

      I understood the risk, and know the chances of seeing rewards is low. So, am looking to at least keep the the creator from walking away for free. I would think something like a bankruptcy is in order, and force them to sell their assets and provide at least a percentage in refunds.

    50. Michael Sprague
      on May 31, 2016

      So, I'm looking at all the other lies told (aka "updates").... how much money is being wasted on storing the finished/almost finished products? through the updates on the other KS (that I thankfully dodged) there are pics of the same dice towers and collector boxes that are shown in the recent update (but from a year ago).

      I run a screen printing shop, I can't imagine having product just stacked up for a year+ taking up room.

Show older comments