Funded! This project was successfully funded on April 20, 2012.

Update #29

Sound in The Banner Saga


Greetings! As you guys know, we do a monthly progress report to keep you up to date on how progress is coming on the game. We'll have the usual progress report coming just next week with lots of progress happening this month on the single player Saga.

Today we have an excellent update from Kpow Audio, who have been doing an astounding job with the sound and audio implementation on the game, which you can already get a good dose of in the Factions beta.

Kpow Audio is Michael Theiler and Peret von Sturmer, working remotely from Sydney, Australia, and what you hear from them are thanks to your support, without which we'd be doing our own foley, and that would not have been pretty. I very highly recommend checking this out even if you don't know much about sound in games. The depth in each branch of game development can be pretty fascinating stuff.

I'll leave it to Michael from Kpow to explain:

Situating an Ambience

When creating ambiences for games (this applies equally to film), I am striving to make them blend into the background, and not mask any important in game sounds. For most ambiences, these are the most important qualities that I am attempting to resolve.

In order to achieve this, I need to firstly focus on the repetition and timing between audio occurrences in the sounds. This means spacing sounds, and adding and removing sound occurrences in my audio sequence. I then work on the frequencies in the sounds, using equalization to mold them into the right sound. Finally, I work on their sound propagation, and the sound of the space in which they are to inhabit. These are the steps necessary to mould sound into something suitable for the space. Just adding reverb is not enough - the sound needs to be purpose built for the space’s reverberation and delay treatment.

Sprinkling Sounds
The first task I need to do to ensure the ambience retreats into the background is to select the correct sounds. The more particular you are about the sounds you choose, the better results you will get. Don’t settle for an slightly inappropriate sound if you know its going to be a lot of work to massage the audio to make it sound right for the space. Often I will find nice long stereo files that contain approximately the right sounds, but they always need some work to be made to fit the particular space I am attempting to create. Usually they will need to be edited, removing anything that pops out and distracts you from the space and time of the location. I say time because often with an ambience the frequency of occurrence of particular sounds is something that needs to be considered. If there is too much happening, the space feels cluttered and busy. Even if you are depicting a busy location such as an outdoor market, or a busy mall, too frequent a bunch of sounds together and you have a mess. This kind of cacophony can be used as an effect, but in games you don’t have control of the player’s orchestration of the world you are creating. Therefore care must be taken to design the sounds in a pleasing, but apparently random manner. These same sensibilities are used when designing a more molecular, procedural ambience - tuning time between ambient audio events is what makes these spaces feel ‘right’. It is something that I learned after doing this for a long while, less is more often than not, more. Keep most things subtle, and let the occasional sound pop out only if it sounds perfect to do so.

Removing anything that pops out is a balancing act. A space is determined by how the sound and its propagation ‘sits’ in the space. We manipulate this with delays and reverberation. If nothing pops out at all, the reverb doesn’t have the material with which to bloom, and therefore describe the space. So I am not trying to get rid of every descriptive sound, I am trying to ensure every sound is right. It sounds the right distance away for the space I am trying to describe, it sounds at the right level (usually low, but not always), it occurs infrequently or frequently enough to be believable.

The next consideration when building an ambience is the frequencies, their relationship, any build-ups of particular frequencies, and the overall mix (which actually comes last). As I mentioned before, I am trying to ensure the ambience sits behind any important close sounds. Every audio building block needs to be eq’d so it plays a background role. Usually the frequencies I am concerned with are the middle frequencies, from around 350Hz to around 2kHz. This varies of course, and I will have chosen audio already that doesn’t contain important information that is loud and overbearing in these frequencies. Also, I am talking by degrees. Everything has these frequencies in them to an extent, I just ensure they are not overwhelming or distracting in any way. After a multitrack of up to 30 channels has been eq’d, usually if an individual channel is solo’d, its surprising how much frequency content has been removed. The overall feel of the ambience needs to be fairly light. If there is too much bass it means when in game you get used to the bass, you start to ignore it, then a bass-heavy weapon or impact or vehicle sound loses its impact as the player has learned to become accustomed to these frequencies, so the contrast is not there. So keeping things well tamed is important.

The final element, often the most time consuming, and probably the most important, is getting the space right for these sounds. They usually need to be pushed back. They often need to be diffuse, and the distance and diffusion usually needs to sound a little more exaggerated than they would in real life in order to create some contrast and depth to your sound design. I like to think of these ambiences as layers. They have depth also - the sounds in them are not from the same distance or perspective - they are from over there, behind that, a block away and behind that hill.

In order to give perspective to these sounds, my setup usually starts at this first example, and morphs from there. I am going to take you through a couple of different mix setups. I use ProTools, so will be describing these techniques using the much maligned behemoth, but these techniques apply equally well to other DAWs.

Spacialisation Setup Number One
The first setup is one I used many times on the ambiences for LA Noire. We didn’t have a procedural system in place for LA Noire, instead we had tracks between 1 min 30 seconds, and three minutes long, that looped, providing the ambience for different locations. There were over 100 different ambience tracks for exteriors and interiors, which faded in and out based on locations.

Once I had chosen the sounds and eq’d them to feel right, I would set up my delay auxiliary channel, and my reverb auxiliary channel. Both the delay and the reverb channel would be set to pre-fader. This way, I can control the apparent distance away that the sound appears, by reducing the amount of direct sound on the sound’s channel. So the signal you hear might be half direct, but all reverb, and some delay, creating a diffuse distant sound.

Automating the send level of the direct to the reverb and to the delay, and automating the reduction of the direct level of the individual tracks leads to a huge amount of variation in perceived distance from the space that the sound has propagated within. It lets me have a version of a sound get louder by having a good amount of direct sound, a little less reverb, and a little delay, therefore sounding closer, but then blooming within the space. Reducing the direct sound and keeping the reverb send up gives the sound a diffuse, more distant quality. Tuning the delay lets you describe the slap off of building, or hillsides, or distant mountains or canyons, or an alley way. This slap is something that quickly clues your ears in to the space around the sound. It may seem a little more crude than a reverb, but it can sound very beautiful, can be instantly evocative, and I believe is a very important ingredient in describing a space.

The relationship between the direct sound, reverberation and the delay begins to build a picture of the space the sounds are occurring in. But if we stopped here, we would not have all the depth that can be achieved with the next step. I always, and I mean always, set up an equalizer after my reverbs and delays, on the same aux channel. This is hugely important, and is a technique that I have found improves mixes in any circumstance. Once its in, I usually start by carving out some highs and lows, usually shelves, but sometimes, if I need to be a little more brutal, I will use a low pass or high pass filter. With ambiences, I am trying to reduce their weight. I need the frequencies that give the ambiences their heavy, suffocating qualities, for other more important sounds, so these areas need to be tamed. The high frequencies also need to go. Often it can feel like the sparkle is leaving your mix, but very high frequency reverbs are not realistic, and often sound bad after any compression. I tend to avoid this sound in my reverbs unless they are for a specific effect. As I do this, I am often fairly brutal at first, and I am listening to the sounds behind the reverb become unveiled. This is where I create depth. The separation between the reverb and the direct sound, as if they are not in the same plane, but a related parallel plane. This is what gives the mix space. It lets you hear the reverb as support, and lets the main sounds function better.

Once the reverbs are done, I do exactly the same thing to the delay. Often with the delay I am a little more extreme, but I also find here is where I can give the description of space even more value. For example, the fast delay in a wood room sounds different to a glass room. Obvious I know, but here is where I can quickly simulate that sound by eq’ing the delay. For a forest, its going to be pretty dead in the high frequencies - I might dampen everything above 1.2kHz. A quarry is going to be a bit more live, but still not have the higher frequencies very present.

And that’s basically it. I am sending all the tracks to a master bus, which has an overall eq that I might take out a little more bass, and a limiter on it that usually never gets hit, and I record out. Then its a case of bringing that stereo file back in, making it loop seamlessly, and I am done.

Spacialisation Setup Number Two
For The Banner Saga, we are doing a more procedural ambience. I approached this a little differently. There are many different spaces in this game, but one of the more important ones is the opening view of the City of Strand. It is a distant view of a small city. I wanted to create the feeling that the city is alive and populated, audibly so from this distance. As it is a seaside city, I used seagulls as my close perspective sounds, and added wind and sea for the mid-distance. I then used shouting and the sound of anvils being struck for the distant city sounds. This worked out well, but getting the distance on these sounds correct took some time.

To get them sounding right, once I had picked out the sounds, I arranged variations of them sequentially in ProTools. This is procedurally generated content, so I needed lots of individual sounds with which to randomise their playback using FMOD Designer, in order to create the ambience. Once arranged, I setup a convolution reverb on their channel, set to something that approximated the slap and diffusion of being in the narrow streets of a stone and wood city I then sent varying amounts of this to my usual reverb auxiliary channel, but this time I had two delays setup to provide the slaps.

These delays were to give a sense of bouncing off the surrounding mountains. There was a medium delay time of around 300ms, and a longer one around 600ms. Once setup the length of delay meant you could hear that these were facsimiles of the sound repeated exactly (despite some eq), so I needed to add another reverb after the delays (on each delays channel), to wash out the delays a little. This started to sound right, but was still a little heavy sounding for the distance, so I went a little harder on the eq’s, with my final settings including some shelving of -16dB at 130Hz and below, and a low pass at 18kHz. I then also have some cutting at 990 Hz of around 10dB and also at 6.5 kHz of around 7dB.

The eq’s on both delays are similar but have some differences - for example the eq on delay 2 has some boosting in the high frequencies as shown in the second eq image.

The delay aux channels levels are also both set fairly low, around -18 to -19, so they are only contributing their character subtly to the mix - it’s not a huge effect, despite being necessary for the sound

The main reverb is a convolution reverb, with an Impulse Response that mimics the sound of a block party, it has some diffusion, as well as some hard surfaces slapping.

The eq after this just tames some bass and cuts some highs, with some lower mids also scooped. This created the sound I was after. Its a fairly diffuse distant yelling and clanking, with a diffuse echo that sounds like it is carried off by the wind. Its a more high frequency echo, so simulates the effect of bass reduction over distance, and the whole effect, although subtle in its execution, is slightly exaggerated and stylised compared to how the sounds would be in real life.

You can hear how it eventually came out here:

And that’s it. The setups I’ve explained above work in almost all cases, and offer a huge amount of controlled tuning to create most spaces you will need.

The only thing left is to go through the specific tools used, though as long as you have a good reverb to start with, most DAWs come with everything else you need.

Equality by DMG Audio
This eq is very transparent. It does not provide any colouration, but it is crystal clear, dependable, and very easy use. The display does a great job of showing what it is doing, and it provides a built in frequency analyser which is often handy.

Reverberate by Liquid Sonics
Until Altiverb is released for PC’s, this is the convolution reverb I have settled on. It is infinitely tweakable, which can be a time sink, but it is usually easy to get the sound you want without too much tweaking. I have boosted its functionality by purchasing some IR’s that are great for Post Production. I believe the ‘block party’ preset I used above was from ‘kinetic sound prism’.

Valhalla Room by Valhalla DSP
This is a beautiful sheeny reverb great for User Interface sounds, but can be used for real spaces if you show some restraint. Its also great for music. I used this to smear the long delays on the distance sounds for the city screen in The Banner Saga.

L2007 Limiter by Massey Plugins
All Massey’s plugins are well priced and extremely useful. I love this limiter for its sound, very transparent. Its fast to setup, and always does what I expect.

Delays are usually just the standard ProTools delays. In the above instances I used the Extra Long Delay II.

An important consideration for me is how quickly the tools I use can get me to the sound I want or hear in my head. The above plugins don’t have a particularly coloured sound, so may not be great for anything that requires a lot of character, and they don’t have a lot of bells and whistles, but for my needs they are great in that I can be efficiently setup, and provide the sound I want, fast. I have created templates that have my sessions set up with all the channels, auxiliaries and sends outlined above, ready to go. This lets me sit down and create, rather than jumping constantly from left to right brain states.


    1. New%20eye.small

      Creator alxnot on January 29, 2013

      A thousand thanks for that amazing update. In all my years reading about camera and audio work in film and video, I've never come across anything as generously detailed as your behind-the-scenes audio post account here. So amazed you took the time to write it. Thank you.

    2. Missing_small

      Creator Doymarn on January 27, 2013

      great update, sound and music are such important elements and thanks for such an in depth insight into your production... excellent material

    3. Missing_small

      Creator Ryan "Keokuk" Smith on January 24, 2013

      I'm very excited to play your game. I think you've got something you can do really deep narrative with some epic strategy tossed in for some sweet sweet game-play.

    4. Daily.small

      Creator Mate Sršen on January 24, 2013

      An amazing article, it really goes quite unexpectedly in-depth into the sound design, which I consider to be a vital but underrepresented discipline in modern game development. Articles like these help a lot, so thank you!

    5. Mokona1.small

      Creator Pogopuschel on January 24, 2013

      Nice update!

      Thank you for sharing so much detail about sound production.

    6. Golem_arcana.small

      Creator Niels on January 24, 2013

      Thanks for this deep insight, that's great to get to see so much detail about how the sound is beeing made.

    7. Dragon%20fractel.small

      Creator _Zed_ on January 23, 2013

      that is fascinating, and really cool. And holy crap, it must take years to get deep into all the UIs for audio creation O.O

    8. Missing_small

      Creator nerdwerds on January 23, 2013

      Nice job! It really sounds good. I can't wait to see the game in action!

pledged of $100,000 goal
seconds to go

See full bio

  • Pledge $5 or more
    You selected

    35 backers

    An exclusive desktop WALLPAPER for your PC, Mac, tablet or mobile device, along with our heartfelt thanks. Choose with or without the logo. Be a part of the movement!

    Estimated delivery:
  • Pledge $10 or more
    You selected

    9031 backers

    A copy of THE BANNER SAGA with all the Chapter 1 content, along with all the big upgrades we're planning to add to the multiplayer, distributed digitally on PC or Mac. Includes all previous rewards.

    Estimated delivery:
  • Pledge $25 or more
    You selected

    4710 backers

    Get the AWESOME SPECIAL EDITION of The Banner Saga. The single player game as described above, plus the digital art book including production art and design sketches, the original soundtrack and desktop wallpaper. On top of all that, as a special thanks we'll include your name in the OFFICIAL CREDITS for the game.

    Estimated delivery:
  • Pledge $50 or more
    You selected

    2735 backers

    Be a real part of The Banner Saga! At this tier we'll provide you a template and you provide us with YOUR OWN CREST DESIGN which we'll put into the actual game. In both single and multiplayer, players will choose a family crest that represent them; this is your chance to get your family or guild symbol into the Banner Saga (must meet a few reasonable decency guidelines - see the FAQ). Includes all previous rewards.

    Estimated delivery:
  • Pledge $50 or more
    You selected

    1850 backers

    SPECIAL POSTER PROMOTION: We've gotten so many requests for just the poster that we can't ignore them any longer! For this special reward, get just the poster (unsigned) and the special edition of the game, no frills. This prize does NOT include the button or the guild crest but DOES include your name in the credits. All higher level donations continue to get the $80 version of this prize. Include an additional $10 for shipping outside the US & Canada.

    Estimated delivery:
  • Pledge $80 or more
    You selected

    513 backers

    A limited edition print of the official game POSTER for The Banner Saga in full movie poster size (24 x 36 inches), SIGNED by the team at Stoic. Look to the left to check out the art. Also, to show off your viking spirit in public we'll include a BUTTON that looks just like the main character's brooch. Includes all previous rewards - please add $10 for shipping outside the US & Canada.

    Estimated delivery:
  • Pledge $100 or more
    You selected

    680 backers

    Your generous donation guarantees that you'll get not just the poster but a T-SHIRT designed exclusively for the Kickstarter campaign (check the art to the left). Once it's over we won't be making any more! Includes all previous rewards - please add $10 for shipping outside the US & Canada.

    Estimated delivery:
  • Pledge $150 or more
    You selected

    241 backers

    Austin Wintory, composer of the hit game "Journey", will be providing limited edition PHYSICAL COPIES OF THE SOUNDTRACK, hand-signed by the composer himself. Different from the official soundtrack, once the campaign ends these special edition CDs won't be available again. As part of the special music promotion, the donations we receive from this prize category go directly to help fund an all-out, full orchestral score for the game, recorded in a live studio! Includes all previous rewards.

    Estimated delivery:
  • Pledge $250 or more
    You selected

    47 backers Limited (3 left of 50)

    Don't just support the Banner Saga, own a piece of art from it. This tier features a physical, numbered ANIMATION CEL from the game, just like how they used to do it back in days of yore. Choose one of two pivotal characters from the game. Includes all previous rewards - please add $15 for shipping outside the US & Canada.

    Estimated delivery:
  • Pledge $350 or more
    You selected

    17 backers Limited (33 left of 50)

    Get an autographed copy of the performance parts from the recording sessions; the SHEET MUSIC used by the actual musicians who play on the score. Needless to say, this prize will be a limited run. As part of the special music promotion, the donations we receive from this prize category go directly to help fund an all-out, full orchestral score for the game, recorded in a live studio! Includes all previous rewards.

    Estimated delivery:
  • Pledge $600 or more
    You selected

    50 backers All gone!

    Kickstarter is a chance not just to fund the game but to offer art for the sake of art. Get a full-sized, 12 x 36 FRAMED LANDSCAPE work of art inspired by the incredible American master Eyvind Earle. No logos, no gimmicks; numbered and signed by the artist. Check it out in the details to the left. Includes all previous rewards - please add $20 for shipping outside the US & Canada.

    Estimated delivery:
  • Pledge $800 or more
    You selected

    17 backers Limited (8 left of 25)

    Immortalize something meaningful to you in The Banner Saga. Send us a photo of YOUR OWN HEIRLOOM, memento or just something you'd like to show your friends and we'll turn it into a relic of value and power. We'll work with you to come up with a unique name and description that could include anything from a mysterious inscription to giving off a certain aura. You'll personalize it and make a coveted piece of gameplay by choosing from a list of rarities and in-game bonuses it provides. Doesn't look very viking-themed you say? That's ok, the marketplaces trade in items pillaged from all over the world. Because this includes all previous rewards, please add $20 for shipping outside the US and Canada

    Estimated delivery:
  • Pledge $1,200 or more
    You selected

    10 backers All gone!

    We're incredibly excited about this one. We've partnered with an amazing artist to turn our landscape artwork into a 3-dimensional SHADOWBOX that replicates the feeling of parallax you get from traveling across the land. Framed with a glass cover and coming in at 20 x 16 inches this is a serious piece of art. Numbered and signed. Includes all previous rewards - don't worry about the shipping cost; you're good.

    Estimated delivery:
  • Pledge $2,500 or more
    You selected

    7 backers All gone!

    The gods may be dead but they're not forgotten. BECOME A VIKING GOD in the actual game. We'll create a unique deity with your likeness and work with you on a great name and backstory for him or her. You'll appear in the game in various forms of effigy and be written into the lore, where all may see. Includes all previous rewards. Email us for more info.

    Estimated delivery:
  • Pledge $4,500 or more
    You selected

    0 backers Limited (2 left of 2)

    You are invited to personally ATTEND the music's recording sessions in Los Angeles or elsewhere later this year. This will include a day of hanging out with all of us at the recording studio, and lunch (on us). You will also receive a signed, leather-bound book compiling all of the game's music (produced as a one-off and therefore never commercially for sale) and earn a Music Associate Producer credit in the game and on the album. Not enough? Austin will personally compose an original 30-second ringtone, just for you! As part of the special music promotion, the donations we receive from this prize category go directly to help fund an all-out, full orchestral score in the game recorded in a live studio! Please note: this is a special case prize. While it does include the signed CD and the sheet music, it does not include any of the previous rewards. This one's for serious music fans. You must be able to travel to the Los Angeles area or elsewhere. If you're interested in this prize you must contact us to make arrangements before the end of the Kickstarter campaign.

    Estimated delivery:
  • Pledge $5,000 or more
    You selected

    3 backers All gone!

    We'll rotoscope and ANIMATE YOU, personally, into the game doing an attack or using a special ability so you, too, can look like a badass viking. How many chances will you have to be animated into a 2D game? Backers must be local or able to travel to the Austin/Georgetown area. Afterwards, let's get some lunch. Includes all previous rewards, do we even need to say it at this point? Email us for more info.

    Estimated delivery:
  • Pledge $10,000 or more
    You selected

    1 backer All gone!

    We have so many prizes now we had to compile them all into ONE FINAL, HUGE MEGA-PRIZE. The Executive gives you every prize we have to offer (except for the rotoscope shoot), including the viking god and attending the recording session. On top of that, you will be given an Executive Music Producer credit in the game and on the album. Lastly, receive a framed copy of the Banner Saga main theme, each note inscribed by hand by Austin Wintory, who will also be kind enough to sign his work. Has anything like this even been done before? Please contact us before donating at this tier.

    Estimated delivery:
Funding period

- (32 days)