Unbelievable. All that swimming and just BARELY keeping ahead of the sharks (and your friends) has paid off. You've reached an island, but not just any island; it's the Island of Nowhere Atoll, home to the famous scare faires.
You've only heard tales passed about the crew of various ships you've worked. Stories of frightening (but harmless) monsters, cunning monster tamers, and the scare faires themselves, where monster trainers try to scare the most people with their captured and raised monsters.
As you make your way up the beach, you remember the source of the tales in particular: this is where Mayday's next project, the set-collecting & resource gathering Isle of Monsters, takes place.
While you finish drying yourself off at a convenient towel stand next to a dunk tank at the scare faire, you overhear how to play from the locals: