Use this space to cheer the creator along, and talk to your fellow backers.
Have a question?
The kickstarter that made me give up on Kickstarter.
Seems to be officially deserted.... Really a shame :(
I was on the beta, and frankly it had nothing better than v1 sold as two separate products on iOS. Frown at yourself in shame.
This does seem a dead project and a waste of an investment at this point. We're almost five years in now. I watch a lot of one or two person projects take far less time, with the devs also working full time jobs outside of their project. Sad.
I miss Fargoal the original on my tablet and phone - any chance that one can be updated?
Just checking in to see if anything's changed. Hope springs eternal and all that.
Welp. It's officially 2018. Hope we hear something concrete this year :/
I'm just dropping in to see if there's still a pulse. The Beta was very nearly a polished product, and I keep the expired app there on my phone next to TestFlight in antici... pation. I'm well aware how real life changes plans, though. A little update from Anthony or Jeff would be much appreciated.
I can no longer play the first game on iOS because it’s not 64-bit. Any timeline on release?
How about a little update for the PC version ?
Glad to hear that, thank you!
Dear Fargoal 2 Supporters:
We will work on a more detailed update by Saturday to send out to all supporters, but the short answer is that we have made some recent progress toward a release candidate, and now all the dungeon levels and types are switched on and functioning well.
In fact, I was just playtesting wading through water a couple of weeks ago, and reporting minor bug-fixes for Anthony to work on.
News upcoming (in the update this coming weekend) about the next beta that we hope to send out within the next three to four weeks…
I know it has been sooooo slow in coming, but it is most-definitely *not* dead!
Is someone still around here ? Would be nice to get an update.. or is the project finally dead ?
I just had an hour of fun playing the last beta anyway; I believe it will come out and I believe it will still be fun :)
I am for one, are still hopeful for this project, not that I have any time to play it. I went from being single, to be married and with two kids, which took up all of my spare time. BUT I still want to see it delivered and knowing my money have gone to good use instead of....... nothing.
Thanks Jeff for the mini-update. I'm a big fan of this project and the timeline is not very important to me, as long as progress continues and we hear something once in awhile. I strongly encourage occasional updates even when there is little to report -- it goes a long way even if you fear it will just remind backers how long it's been. All the best!
@Kevin Reynolds - Thanks for the info on the display issues. I will pass that on to Anthony so he can look into the issue.
@Steven Picard, we are very sorry that our project continues to be delayed. We hope to have a new update pushed sometime early in this new year (2017), and feel we are getting ever closer about an official release.
No matter what we know we've disappointed many of our backers about how long it has been taking us to get the game done and published, but please know that we have not given up, and we will strive to get more progress in this new year.
I'm hoping this can get wrapped up soon.
OK, it's been in development for over four years now. Surely it's time to make it feature-complete, fix the remaining bugs, and send it on its way?
sad, thanks for taking my money and not giving us what you promised
So this was just a flat out 50 grand scam, or?
The last two betas have been unplayable on windows using a 4k notebook display. The display appears as extremely zoomed in, to the point you only see a GIANT "Create Hero" text on the screen. Even the "Sword of Fargoal" logo is too large to fit on the screen. If you click "Create Hero", most of the "creation" content is off screen. Nothing I have done has changed this. Is there a better place than kickstarter to report "bugs"?
Received the new beta. Thanks for coming through!
Hello Fargoal 2 Kickstarter supporters:
This is a long-overdue response to some of the posts and comments that you've given us over the past few months.
And, yes, we definitely owe you the latest update on all-things-Fagoal. I plan to speak with Anthony and, between he and I, we will make sure to send out a progress update later this week. We know we continue to be embarrassingly overdue on the project as a whole, but are committed to the the game ultimately being released come heck or high water.
Regarding the forums: We had some forum corruption issues and were not able to restore the original database. To some degree we were able to save most of the posts, but the membership database was irretrievable. I am of the mind that we should probably set up a clean copy of the forums and then import what we can. Hence, I will work on getting something up (and imported) over the next couple of weeks. Once that is done we will re-invite Fargoal 2 backers so you can join and we can start to rebuild our communications structure.
I will also check in with Paul about his current plan to begin helping to guide Anthony again once his other project begins to wind down. As many of you know, the modern version of Fargoal is largely Paul's creative brainchild (Paul being co-owner of the game). However, it has always presented a challenge that Paul has spent the lion's share of the development time due to his coding abilities when I'm afraid I have none (my skills revolving more around design, art direction, etc.). That is one of the main reasons why we brought in Anthony to help cover that coding imbalance. However, as brilliant of a coder as Anthony is, the code base is so large and so complex that it has remained a very large undertaking and has continued to be very slow going. Of course this was never our intent, and we feel deeply sorry that things have played out this way.
I will make sure a more game-specific update is sent out to all backers by or before this coming Friday, July 1, 2016 in the evening. We will also put a plan in place for when we will release the next beta. The newest beta will cover both PC/Mac/Linux as well as an iOS test for those of you who are iOS-only.
Thanks you each and every one of you who have put up with us during this process, and even for those of you who have not — which we completely understand and know we deserve the heavy criticism. We want more than anything to make good, and we will continue — though we know much too slowly — to work toward doing so.
At least release the latest Beta please!
So... Whatever happened to this? I feel like this was "almost done" for at least 2 years.
@Ben - Can you explain your understanding and what information you have that Paul is moving on to bigger and better things? If Paul is working for Jeff on this game, then a contract should be in place and there should be absolutely no "considering coming back" to the project. Sounds like their is a good deal of speculation from your post. Are you a friend? Do you have an inside loop? We have no idea what is actually going on since it's very clear that communication has gone to absolute crap. It's been 7 months since the last update and I we were promised on multiple occasions that we would get monthly updates. This project is 3 YEARS overdue.
This comment has been removed by Kickstarter.
The owner(Jeff) has had periods of time where he just vanishes.. Unreachable. It's just one of those things we won't know a reason for unless he tells us whats the deal.
I feel the developers shouldn't get a bad rap for this, they've done work.. Something that they should be paid for. I saw a discussion in the Fargoal forum that shed a bit of light, there is a claim that payments weren't happening. I had hoped to see Jeff personally respond to that, but the entire forum has been taken down since then.
We definitely deserve more info and respect, fudge.. I gave up $70 for this! My point is that I feel the negative talk about the developers(Madgarden in particular) is unwarranted, Jeff should be the one with the answers for us. People have to make a living.
Nice to hear, but if that is true, then why hasn't the owner responded to any of this?
And why are they making other games instead of the one we paid them to make?
I think we earn more info and respect for backing SoF2.
Just thought I'd throw it out there that I spoke to the programmer Anthony about a month back, he did confirm that he's still working on the game and is currently upgrading the project to SDL 2 to make it easier to get on Steam.
I know that isn't much to go by, just thought I'd share what I've heard. Hoping this project will eventually be given the attention it deserves. Its been way too long.
This is about as sideways as a kickstarter has gotten for me. Next were going to hear that he ran out of funds getting to the beta, and that he can't put any more time in until he gets additional funding from some nebulous source. Oh wait...
Nice scam. We fund it, and then you tell us you'll work on it IF your other NEWER project is a success. How about either refunding us or working on the game?
@stutzj Yeah, i was shocked too, And no a word from a SoF2 creatores. =\
@Alex - "You" is not you but madgarden.
@Alex - wait....what? IF Death Road does well enough THEN you can find some time for Fargoal 2?? So I take it is a IF that this project will get done. We're approaching three years over estimated deadline with five months since the last update. Why would you post on twitter with info like this?
I never complain about slow kickstarters. I know that I'm making a donation towards a game that I hope will exist, but this one really makes me sad. I watched the live stream as the project made it's goal and felt great about my tiny part in getting this game made. The lack of communication has been very discouraging.
Hey, guys! Can you comment this tweet?
Paul Pridham @madgarden 20 march
Had to put Fargoal 2 on hold previously for financial reasons. If Death Road does well enough, will be able to spend some time on it again.
I think its about SoF2 WE BACKED? ;)
Where is the game? Where is the news? Where is money?
I am extremely disappointed in the lack of updates and progress toward SoF2. After many other backers have posted in the comments, updating every 6-12 months is unacceptable. Transparency and communication on how the game is shaping toward release would be nice for the $50k investment the community made BACK IN 2013. Three years later and all we have is a beta...ridiculous.
I was honestly excited about this project and I remember helping Jeff (along with a lot of other people) making this true. After three years, I honestly feel really disappointed and irritated by the lack of communication.
I really hope people involved into this production understand how much this is going to impact on their reputation: we are not talking about 5k here, the campaign - if I'm not wrong - managed to reach 50k to make Sword of Fargoal 2 true.
If this project it is not going to happen, please just tell us and be honest, which is definitely better than updating this every 12 months trying to keep people quiet.
Wow, do I ever feel like a sucker. As someone else pointed out: Our nostalgia was taken for a ride. At this point, 3 years into the cycle, scam is about all I can say as well. Jeff, the comments sections says, "Be respectful and considerate." I wish you had done the same.
We're well into 2016 and just a couple of months shy of 3 years from the expected release date, which was May of 2013.
Is this ever going to ship, or is it just another failed Kickstarter campaign?
Pat: for me (on MacOS X), an icon appears in the upper right when standing on stairs. You can click the icon or press the ctrl key to go up or down.
Is anyone discussing game play on the betas anywhere?
How do you use stairs? It's been over a year since I last tried out a beta, and I've tried every keystroke I can think of, to no avail...