Share this project

Done

Share this project

Done
Magnetism and physics are made visible with ferrofluid. Help fund a highly engineered container that showcases this unique material.
Magnetism and physics are made visible with ferrofluid. Help fund a highly engineered container that showcases this unique material.
341 backers pledged $49,028 to help bring this project to life.

Use this space to cheer the creator along, and talk to your fellow backers.

Have a question?

Only backers can post comments. Log In
    1. robby hayes on

      Holidays are over. Update your backers. Tired of seeming these comments? Update your backers and send us what you promised. Do what you promised to do.

    2. Missing avatar

      Jai Ramachandran on

      so timeline? update? anything?

    3. Missing avatar

      Jai Ramachandran on

      So when can we expect an email confirming our addresses? A timeline would be nice (side note, in the time this project has been ongoing I have switched jobs twice and moved to a different state)

    4. wesley chang on

      3 years ago, this was the 2nd Kickstarter project I had backed. 3 years and 16 more projects later, it's still the only one I have yet to receive. :-/ (And no, it's existence as a blurry background prop isn't consolation. It's further reminder that many that backed the project here have yet to physically handle a tangible product for their faith and support.)

    5. Seth on

      "A blurry background prop in a movie" .. Quite the metaphor.

    6. David Markus Creator on

      @Dave Fishman:

      That's exactly what I intend to do. Im ready to just close the book on this. I'm sorry it's not at all what I hoped for this.
      Also if it's any consolation it was a blurry background prop in a movie.
      http://davidmarkus.us/gotg (dot) jpg

    7. Dave Fishman on

      Dear god just send me the parts ill put it together myself ! i dont care about the finish thats not 100% what you wanted

    8. Missing avatar

      Reed Martin on

      David,
      Please stop ignoring your backers. Share with us the good, bad and ugly. Failure to communicate out of fear is the worst thing you can do. Start typing RIGHT NOW we need to hear from you. It will only get worse if you continue to not to update.

      The Internet forgives but it does not forget. The question you must resolve for yourself is how you want to be known and remembered. At this point you only have two choices left - either as a guy who miss-managed a project, came clean and did his best to resolve it -OR- as someone who committed fraud and ripped people off.

      Ignoring the people who put their trust and money behind you is the worst thing you can do.
      Be truthful and be thorough. We have a right to know what is going on. You took $50,000 dollars from backers - this won't go away.

    9. Jeff Flowers on

      Gotta agree with the others. What's going on... Now's the time to share.

    10. robby hayes on

      8 months with no update. The holidays are over, put up an update. Send us our stuff. Or give us our money back. Stop pussy footing around and get it done.

    11. Missing avatar

      Michael Chen on

      I like to request my money back please.

    12. David Markus Creator on

      My goal at this point is to distribute the parts as people have requested. I'm working with my ferrofluid supplier to create a plan for after the holiday rush slows down.

    13. Jeff Flowers on

      Just tell us what is happening - or at the very least, shut down the website. It just isn't right to have this up at all at this point. It looks a lot like hubris.

    14. Missing avatar

      Monkeywaffles on

      Yea, just send what you have. Heck, I'm even up in your new state, I'll drive up and pick the darn half-completed parts up in persion. It's going on 3 years man. Time to send out at least somethign to the people you spent 50,000 dollars of their money. It appears you still check this as Jeff's message of the product showing up as for sale has been rectified. Kindly ship whatever you can out like.. when you read this. 3 years of putting it off, time to cut your losses and move on with your own life, and let these 350 people do the same.

    15. Jeff Flowers on

      http://getferrite.com/products/ferro

      It appears to be an actual shipping product. I do believe that in the past, it was listed as "sold out" - is this an actual shipping product now? I was going to buy it off the website, but my gut just wouldn't let me do it.

      So I ask - has anyone attempted to buy one off of his website? If so, did you get it? I think that it would be highly disrespectful if these are being sold and we're S.O.L.

      At this point - I'm in for the combo, but would accept a ferro (and would feel fine with it too.) To close the books if you will.

    16. robby hayes on

      Send us something. Tell us something. Let us know what the "game changer" was. Communicate something. Please.

    17. Missing avatar

      Steve Gordon on

      David,

      It's been two months since your last mini update. 6 months since your last full update. This really isn't any way to treat your supporters. I know you're disappointed with how things turned out, but silence isn't the responsible or appropriate way to go here. Please provide an update, even if it's just to say that you're shipping out the parts and we have to assemble them on our own. I'm sure the vast majority of people would take that trade at this point in the game.

    18. Missing avatar

      Luther Burrell on

      Please send me the pieces. Please, please.

    19. Soochon Radee on

      David, I think you need to cut your losses and send everything out to everyone regardless of what you think about the finish. You have all the parts and I'm sure that if you offered this option a lot of people would choose it. They'll still make some great Christmas presents.

    20. Missing avatar

      Jai Ramachandran on

      Check this out guys: Golden Ferrofluid for $60 (and I am sure it will ship in less than 3 years)

      http://www.thinkgeek.com/product/hshl/…

    21. Missing avatar

      Jai Ramachandran on

      David Markus... Fraud

    22. Seth on

      i comically check back on this project from time to time... thinking there is going to be some kind of new info... update.. whatever. i think its safe to bet that there is absolutely nothing... the project has failed... at least just respond back and say that. just admit defeat. the "game changer" update is so past due that it is meaningless at this point. just come out and say the project is dead.

    23. Dave Fishman on

      5 months without an update ... Dude just send us what you have ... Starting to think you don't even have anything to send us ... Just pocketing the cash

    24. Matt Beemsterboer on

      I recall discussion of the product 'finish' from months and months ago and I, for one, am with every person who said they didn't care about the finish being perfect. I am also in the camp that thought the 'unfinished' version looked great. So, what's the deal? Rather than put the items together unfinished, a process you know full well how to do, you want to cop out and just send all of the pieces and let us just have at it?
      I've never commented on here about this because, frankly, I've already given you my money and long since gotten over the idea of having this as a cool desk piece. (Luckily I don't have a standard work desk anyway...) But to me the idea of getting a bunch of pieces in the mail makes me far more disgruntled than the idea of having to wait another 6 months for the finished product. I'd much rather have you, the expert, put it together whenever you have the time so I do, someday, get the reward that was promised.

    25. Jeff Flowers on

      Echoing what has been recently said - I really think that we could (perhaps deserve) some closure.

      Stuff happens, I would be happy knowing that it just didn't connect in the end. Knowing this coupled with how the monies were spent - this being key - would allow me to put this matter to bed.

    26. Missing avatar

      Jai Ramachandran on

      David - With all due respect, we have been waiting for this magical update since June 25th, close to four fucking months ago! Cut the crap. Enough with the promised updates. You have had the "finish" problem now for 6+ months. Please just send me the pieces I paid for and I will figure out how to put it together myself. Surely it will take me less 6 months to do that.

    27. Fabio Pettinati on

      Hi David... I've supported about 50 projects, some quite expensive, others quite fun. The main reason I pledge is to help people bring their dreams to life, whatever they may be. Every once in a while dreams get a life of their own and become nightmares haunting their creators. That's OK and part of growing up as a person. Who among your backers has not failed? I have and a couple of times at that, both personally and professionally. You know what? Life goes on. Sometimes it's best to simply admit that the dream is gone, turn the page and move on. If you've reached that point, rather than continuing being haunted just admit that the obsession to get it done is pointless. I'm sure people will appreciate that honesty; I for one will. Wishing you good luck in your future endeavors.

    28. Jeff Flowers on

      @David - the fact that so many people are actually still are checking up on this project, ought to demonstrate to you that there is still interest/value. With that in mind, I hope your next update comes quickly (it doesn't need to be perfect - just be completely honest.)

    29. David Markus Creator on

      Yes, Kickstarter tends to become very "hands off" as soon as they get their percentage. This is true for both backers and creators. I have read your comments and I will work on more comprehensive response, however for the time being here is a summary: The parts for all rewards exist but I am disappointed with the surface finish the manufacturer supplied. Trying to rectify this issue has been the main source of delays with the project being completed. At this point I believe my only option to bring any kind of closure to this project is to send out the parts as-is and un-assembled. I will do my best to clarify more on this in the full update.

    30. Missing avatar

      Brian Kieffer on

      I heard back from Kickstarter. Here was their response:

      -----------------------------

      Thanks for reaching out. I’m sorry to hear that the creator has not done a better job of communicating. We've reached out to them with a reminder of their obligations to their backer community, in addition to having forwarded along your concerns and those of your fellow backers. While we're disheartened that they have not yet updated you and other backers on the status of their project, we're unable to force them to do so. It's the creator's responsibility to communicate and complete their project as promised.

      Backing a project on Kickstarter is an expression of trust. Backers pledge in hopes of helping a creator bring their idea to life. This interaction can lead to the creation of new and exciting things, but it’s also important to remember that sometimes complications might arise that prevent a project from unfolding as planned, or even from happening at all. This isn’t ideal for creators or backers, but we hope that both parties will try to communicate with each other through these developments. We’re sorry that this hasn’t been the case with this project, but hope that you’ll continue to back projects that you’re excited about.

      Thank you again for sharing the experience that you have had with this project. Although we are unable to offer refunds, we are constantly working to improve the vetting process for creators and feedback such as this is exactly what helps us do so. We hope that you’ll continue to be an active member of the Kickstarter community as we learn and grow with our community.

      -----------------------------

      Basically, there's no way they can force David to do anything, which I understand.

    31. Missing avatar

      Reed Martin on

      Hello David,

      Please don't ignore your supporters. Issue and update - any update. Share with us the good, bad and ugly. Failure to communicate out of fear is the worst thing you can do. Start typing right now we need to hear from you. It will only get worse if you continue to not to update.

    32. Jeff Flowers on

      @David - now is probably the time for a real update. I think you owe everyone here that much.

      @Brain - I would love to know what you learn from kickstarter, I think others would also like to know as well.

      Personally, I would just like to know what is going on - closure basically. This was such an exciting project, and like any great endeavor - sometimes things don't connect. However, did things just not connect - or was there a lack of care taken by the project leader? This is what really bugs me. Knowing one way or the other, would set my mind at rest.

    33. Dave Fishman on

      Smh can't believe the lack of responsibility and ownership here ... First and worst kickstarted project I have backed.

    34. Missing avatar

      Brian Kieffer on

      I sent a message to Kickstarter. They'll probably just tell me that they can't do anything, but at the very least they should put this thing out of its misery.

    35. Missing avatar

      Brian Kieffer on

      Updates were promised, and that deadline has also come and gone.

      In accordance with Kickstarter's newly revised TOS, I'm demanding that David provide a full accounting of where our money was spent, and either ship what he has so far, or issue refunds.

      I'd be far more understanding if we had simply received updates as promised.

    36. Don Pattee
      Superbacker
      on

      I just set a calendar reminder for the 3-year funding anniversary...

    37. Missing avatar

      Jai Ramachandran on

      I just don't understand why he kept lying to backers. At this point it is clear that he is not going to get the project done. I wonder if he really ever even ordered the parts? The world may never know...

    38. Debora Richards on

      wonder what calender he uses???

    39. Missing avatar

      Brian Kieffer on

      This is the way the project ends.
      This is the way the project ends.
      This is the way the project ends.
      Not with a bang, but a whimper.

    40. Missing avatar

      Andrew on

      Now more than a month since the supposed "game changer" that was supposed to be revealed the next week... it is now more than 3 months since the last official update, over 2 years past the date when the items were supposed to be delivered in the first place, and David has now been holding our money for more than TWO AND A HALF YEARS.

    41. Philip Melemed on

      Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose...

    42. David Gaipa
      Superbacker
      on

      @David, I would love to hear about that game changer now.

    43. Missing avatar

      Monkeywaffles on

      I think you should just send what you have. No 'waiting for hex wrenches', we can all find our own. No 'writing up an assembly manual' you can post it online later, theres only a few parts. No more excuses or delays please.

    44. Missing avatar

      Jai Ramachandran on

      David - I give up. Have fun with my $150

    45. Jeff Flowers on

      Love to know it as well. Please share.

    46. Missing avatar

      Jai Ramachandran on

      So, update? What is the game changing development?

Show older comments