Yes they will be the same quality shown in the pictures. The "with in reason" is to prevent people from requesting 50 different colors on their boards.
You want them painted just like the pictures? Sure thing!
Painted blue themed? Sure thing!
Green glowing flames and lava instead of red? Sure thing!
50 colors of the rainbow? Nope.
Though if you have something super special in mind we can work it out outside of KS, but that would not be included in the pledge here.