Share this project


Share this project

A sauce made especially for burgers and inspired by the secret sauces at America's best burger joints.
A sauce made especially for burgers and inspired by the secret sauces at America's best burger joints.
1,320 backers pledged $23,724 to help bring this project to life.

Use this space to cheer the creator along, and talk to your fellow backers.

Have a question?

Only backers can post comments. Log In
    1. Missing avatar

      AuronStarglider778 on November 11, 2016

      After two years, I guess we now know what happened to them - when you go to their website, this message now appears:

      "This domain has recently been listed in the marketplace. Please click here to inquire." Indicating they've gone out of business.

    2. Stephen Wesche on September 4, 2014

      Is there any way to get more of this?

    3. Missing avatar

      Div3r5ity on April 2, 2014

      i loved the sauce when i got it, i ordered like a dozen but the batch i got was set to expire in like 3 weeks after i recieved them i was kinda dissapointed about that but i would buy more

    4. Stephen Wesche on March 26, 2014

      Hey guys, any updates on the company? I really enjoyed the sauce!

    5. Missing avatar

      Grant Richardson on February 3, 2014

      Has anybody heard any updates on Gotham Co? I loved my first batch of sauce, ordered a new bottle and it was not the same as my first one. I've tried to email them a few times but haven't gotten a response.

    6. Missing avatar

      AuronStarglider778 on November 30, 2013

      It's been a long time since we backed this project. While I've long since received my two bottles (which were fairly decent), I cannot help but wonder - how have things been going for Gotham Sauce Co.?

      Any breakthroughs in getting your product on more shelves?

    7. Greenfire Farms on September 27, 2013

      Wow! Put it on my burgers and ooh la la! Excellent. Very pleased with this project.

    8. Missing avatar

      Michael Rosenthal on September 22, 2013

      Pretty close to 1 year now.

      Are you walking it from ny to los angeles?

    9. Missing avatar

      Phil on September 8, 2013

      I still haven't received any order or heard anything from you since your last update email in March

    10. Anders Flink
      on August 20, 2013

      Never got my sauce, and I tried emailing. Please respond.

    11. Nick Dechnicz
      on July 17, 2013

      Hi, i still haven't received mine, how long is this going to take??

    12. Rich on June 2, 2013

      Still have not received mine, a replacement would be cool guys.

    13. Missing avatar

      Sveinung Kvist
      on May 11, 2013

      Hi ya. Got mine some months ago (Norway)
      It's perfect on my whaleburgers :)

      Ok. Jokes away, I gotta say the sauce is superb. Thx really love it.

    14. Missing avatar

      freddy on May 7, 2013

      Haven't received mine either, sent you an email but didn't get a reply. I left a comment here but it was deleted.
      Any news on the shipping?

      It should go to Germany and I gave you all the extra details in time.

    15. Nick Dechnicz
      on April 25, 2013

      Haven't received mine yet, sent an email and didn't get a reply.
      Any chance on an update or confirmation?

    16. Missing avatar

      Robert Parrell on April 24, 2013

      The bottle looks small but there's quite a bit in it. Used it on a couple dinners now so around 8 burgers + 4 hot dogs and it's about half gone. Haven't used it sparingly but just slathering it on. So I'd say the bottle size is big enough for what I pledged.
      The only complaint I can really think of is that it tastes exactly like a dipping sauce a burger chain has used here in Sweden for years (Hot Creole at Max Hamburgerrestauranger AB). But I like that dipping sauce so I'm also fine with it :) .
      My biggest wish is that the bottles you could buy off their site were larger since the shipping cost adds a lot when you live outside North America.

    17. Rich on April 22, 2013

      Not received mine, uk here

    18. Kane Charlson
      on April 12, 2013

      I never got my sauce, have sent two e-mails with no reply. So I thought I'd try here as well, a simple reply would have been great. Little bit frustrated though.

    19. Sean Lee on April 1, 2013

      I, too, just opened my box and was surprised how small the bottles were...I kinda thought I'd get the one in the pic... =(

    20. Missing avatar

      Tom DiRienzo on April 1, 2013

      Never got my sauce, and I tried emailing, so I figured I would try here too.

    21. Michael Sena on March 30, 2013

      Hey TSBS - I'm happy with the sauce, but kind of unhappy with the size! I thought we'd be getting the one in the picture on the kickstarter. I guess I never checked the updates because I can see now there's a picture of the production line and all the smaller bottles are there... but yeah, I just wanted to comment on that.

    22. Jeffrey Bower on March 25, 2013

      You'll have to let us know when it hit's stores and what stores (or if it's available online). Had the family try it and they LOVED it! Great recipe! :)

    23. Vinzius
      on March 19, 2013

      Just received my two bottles (france). Didn't taste it yet... "soon" :)

    24. Stephanie Lindström
      on March 19, 2013

      Received the sauce yesterday ( I live in Finland). Absolutely wonderful, tastes really good! Only sad part is I have only one bottle (admittedly a bit small one) and your website says you don't ship international just yet. I will definitely buy more if I can!

    25. Heiko Alhaeuser on March 15, 2013

      Where can I buy it in NYC?

    26. Matt Dusterhoft on March 14, 2013

      I live in Illinois and I have yet to receive mine. Any ideas when I might see it?

    27. Michael Yong on March 14, 2013

      Received my sauce today in Australia. I was just wondering if anyone else has had one of their bottles opened? One of my bottles had plastic around the cap whilst the other one didn't. When I unscrewed the lid, the seal had also been lifted. I'm not going to use this bottle because of this.

      I thought perhaps it was opened by customs, however the box doesn't look like it had been opened or resealed and there's no Australian customs stamp or anything on the box.

      Also, I didn't pay postage on my pledge (noted in survey) so I figured I would have received payment info or something before they shipped the sauce. Perhaos I missed an email or something?

    28. jackson stein on March 14, 2013

      i got my sauce last week and i live in alaska. i forgot i was getting anything then one day i had a box in the mail. it was an amazing surprise. i tried the sauce and love it. i found out that its perfect in a ruebin sandwich. thanks alot

    29. Matt Zitron on March 12, 2013

      Got my sauce today, I'm in the UK.

      Really like the sauce, but I'd have liked a bigger bottle too!

    30. Aaron Lococo on March 11, 2013

      Got the sauce in the other day, I will say it is really good. I think myself like a few others feel a little let down at the size of the bottle. In your picture you show a fairly large burger and a bottle that towers over it. Now we all know thats not a production bottle but, in my mind I thought I'd be getting something comparable. I'd probably continue to pay $10 per bottle for the stuff if it was twice the size of what we were given. A standard bottle of salad dressing or BBQ sauce is 16 - 18 oz and much much cheaper than what we paid here. Now I understand that a large portion of that cost went to shipping costs, probably half, and thats why I'm fine paying the higher price. I feel like the sauce can't cost much to make, I just wonder why you decided to go with the 9oz bottle, how much would your production costs have increased for a 16oz bottle?

    31. Matt Combes on March 8, 2013

      I'm not really understanding the negativity towards the cheaper online sales. Funding a project on Kickstarter, especially one that involves physical production (as opposed to a game or other digital product), means that you are more than likely shelling out more money for something than they might expect to sell it for if they were successful and went retail. You WANT them to be able to sell at retail for less -- why would you want them to continue selling their product for Kickstarter pledge amounts? If anything, we should be HAPPY that they are able to sell their sauce for cheaper than we pledged.

      In addition, opening up orders on their site doesn't necessarily mean they're shipping out those orders before the backers'. There may be instances where someone ordering from the website might get theirs before a backer, but if I had to guess that would only really apply to international backers, who have to deal with long wait times and customs. Taking orders online is just another sign that they're doing well. And as someone who's already halfway through their single bottle, I'm glad that the option to do so exists!

      That being said, I want to echo some of the other backers, re: the thinness of the sauce. I like to smother my burger with this stuff, and it's thin to begin with but the burger's heat makes it even more so, which can then sometimes result in a messy, drippy burger. If you could find an ingredient or thickening agent to give it more of a regular condiment consistency (like mustard), that would be awesome. Otherwise, don't change anything about the recipe. It's absolutely delicious.

    32. Missing avatar

      Brooks Serigne on March 8, 2013

      Received my sauce about 1 week ago, made some burgers last night. The sauce has a good flavor, maybe a little watery. Also when opening the box I discovered such a small bottle. I thought I would be getting a much bigger bottle for $10. Your sauce is very good but I don't know if I can afford a $9 small bottle of sauce. Hopefully you can decrease your price soon.

    33. SK on March 7, 2013

      I got my sauce. It is very tasty and I like it. I agree with Div3r5ity that it is slightly too watery.

      Most of the complaints here are justified. We had every reason to expect a significantly larger bottle of sauce than we did. I did not support this project in order to wait longer and pay more for the sauce than the general public. I have bigger things to worry about than this so, but I don't consider this a "good" kickstarter.

      It makes me think that kick-starter should have a post fulfillment satisfaction survey rating system. I would give a 4/10 in this case.

    34. Missing avatar

      Div3r5ity on March 6, 2013

      My sauce is a little watery, is it suppose to be like that?

    35. Mathieu Kempe on March 6, 2013

      Any idea when I should expect to receive my bottles? I live in Sydney Australia.
      Or may be I should order new one on their website :)

    36. Alex on March 6, 2013

      Just got my sauce a few days ago and just have to say...AWESOME SAUCE!!!! THANK YOU!

    37. laha4902 on March 5, 2013

      I got my sauces a few days ago. They really do make the burgers taste better. I'll be purchasing some more online when my current supply runs out in the near future.

    38. Missing avatar

      itsdan on March 4, 2013

      Received mine a few days ago and now it's gone. I used it on a burger but also as a dipping sauce for onion rings and some other things. I don't mind that it's being sold cheaper, people shouldn't think of Kickstarter as a storefront, it's a crowdfunding. You may have paid a bit more than you can now buy it for retail, but it wouldn't exist AT ALL if you hadn't backed it. Be proud you helped bring something into existence without the need for a small company to sell out to investment banking or a larger company.

      I'll be ordering more (at the newer, lower, better retail pricing).

    39. Brian Chronowski on March 4, 2013

      I received the sauce a few days ago, and it is delicious. Thank you. :)

    40. Kyle on March 1, 2013

      I'll withhold judgement until mine actually show up, although I'm not really liking the sound of things right now.

    41. Missing avatar

      JeffK on March 1, 2013

      I agree, certainly disrespectful and borderline dishonest. I feel like they took our money to start production, sent us a much smaller bottle than promised (maybe 1/3 the size). Then insult us by selling it online cheaper and deliver sooner than the to initial backers. How is this OK with anybody? $10 for a tiny little bottle of sauce (over a buck an oz.). Very disappointed. This is the first kickstarter project I felt I was intentionally taken advantage of.

    42. Missing avatar

      Anant on February 28, 2013

      I don't think its that big of an issue that they are offering it cheaper after this project is over, and quite a few KS projects do the same. They need this influx of cash in the beginning just to start manufacturing it and the start up costs involved. But I do think its an issue when you start selling it elsewhere, before all your backers have received their product. I think that's a bit disrespectful. Compound that with other issues like using a smaller, different bottle then what we saw in the picture and long periods of lack of communication with us, makes me disappointed overall with Gotham Sauce Company. Great product though.

    43. Brys on February 27, 2013

      Received my bottle a day ago (WA State for those awaiting their bottles). I haven't had an opportunity to try it yet due to contracting the plague, but I am a little bummed out to read that the final product is being sold for cheaper than the original pledge.

      I know that when bringing a product to market that things change, especially when deciding on price, but this really isn't something you should have let backers discover on their own.

    44. Missing avatar

      Anant on February 27, 2013

      Got 2 bottles few days ago in the mail. I didn't think I'd actually taste a difference between this and in n out burger sauce or McDonald's or any other but I did and really liked the taste. But I'm torn on between supporting you guys and ordering more or not. I feel like you guys really don't care about your backers who helped fund this project by nearly 5x your goal. I love KS and supporting other peoples dreams and goals but at the same time I feel those people then should be appreciative of the support they received.

    45. Mathieu Kempe on February 27, 2013

      Any idea when I should expect to receive my bottles? I live in Sydney Australia

    46. Missing avatar

      Zachary Weikel on February 27, 2013

      The sauce was mind blowing!!!! My girlfriend and I are already ordering a few more bottle. I do how ever wish it was a little thicker. The sauce reminded me of garlic mayo from pommes fritas in the village.

    47. Paul on February 27, 2013

      May I suggest a "free shipping" coupon or something for us backers? Feeling a bit shafted, haven't received the sauce yet, but am willing to come back for more if it's as amazing as you claim. Plus, I hate shipping fees.

    48. Chris Sewell on February 27, 2013

      First time seeing a Kickstarter project sell a product for cheaper than the backers backed for before all of the shipments have been completed.

      That's just sad.....

      Missing The OCTOBER delivery date is one thing, welcome to Kickstarter I guess where project creators aren't prepared to handle things that come up between the ending of the Kickstarter and fulfillment, But to start selling it before the backers even get their sauce? For less than what the backers paid no less?


    49. jeff on February 26, 2013

      How are you selling them for less then what backers paid and before backers even get theirs?

    50. GroovyDad and the Slap Me Some Skin Kids on February 26, 2013

      Just received my sauce, and am very excited about making burgers tonight!

Show older comments