Use this space to cheer the creator along, and talk to your fellow backers.
Have a question?
I feel like we come here every now and again to mourn the passing of a potentially great project. RIP Harvest Geek, it's a shame we never got to meet you!
This comment has been removed by Kickstarter.
Anyone have any info since Duncan reached out?
I'd say it's about time to sue for breach of contract. Research Seth Quest, and the Hanfree iPad accessory and see how Neil Singh sued and got things taken care of. The creators of the Harvest Geek do not need to go unpunished for this lack of foresight and failure to follow through. If anyone is a lawyer, or has a lawyer in their family, please tell them this story and mention the above pursuit. I will gladly sign-on if anyone wants to pursue legal restitution or our pledges.
Doesn't look positive but anyone have any update?
@Duncan how did you go with his boss? Any response?
I've determined the Mike is currently employed by a small medical marijuana delivery service in Santa Monica called Woah Stork.
I am in communication with the founder of Woah Stork about Mike right now. Its possible he may be able to influence Mike as his boss.
If you are able to calmly and rationally express your desire for a refund / actual product / any kind of communication from the person who stole $50,000 from us, please contact them at firstname.lastname@example.org
Additionally, if you would like to potentially be involved in a small claims court action against Mike Alt in the event that this does not work out, please email me at dca46 [at]. cornell [dot] edu.
Several of the larger backers are already on board.
Very disappointed at the lack of updates and products. If Kickstarter doesn't help or comment I will not be investing in anything else
Looks like he probably screwed everyone over. Looking at his LinkedIn he is now the cofounder of a online marijuana store. That may be where all our money was invested...
Pretty bummed about this project. It is the only one I have backed, because I thought the Kickstarter platform was a good idea. I havn't backed, nor will I back, any other project because of this guy...
I have been patient with this project, but with no communication I'm at the end of my patience. Please update us or refund our money.
Heeellllooo??? Are you alive? Have you screwed us all, or has something terrible happened to you that you can't even post an update? Are you in a coma? KickStarter - surely you have a phone number for this guy? Please reach out to him directly and get us a status. If he was killed in folding chair accident over the summer, we should at least know, and find out who his heir is that could return what's left of our money or ship what's available of the product.
What is going on here? I want my money back! This has gone beyond any reasonable persons ability to be understanding.
I've done both the google form (July 29th), and the "Report this Project" button more recently. I've heard _nothing_ from Kickstarter.
@everyone please fill out this google doc from Kickstarter: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1KvWOM5qEvurz4EaZJch3B_1f3c3WLKe56vRI1gb4uRg/viewform
This guy is a stoner and a fraud! I want my money back! Kickstarter is not doing anything about it.
The open source portion of the project shouldn't be hard to deliver on right? Just make the files public and let the backers pick up where you left off please.
I have compassion for the trials and tribulations that can haunt anyone trying to bring a new product to market; especially those running the gauntlet for the first time. What I have little patience for is the failure of the owner of this project to keep his backers abreast of the projects status. This is not transparency, does not show respect to the backers and does not honor the spirit of Kickstarter. It's time for a gut check and some accountability please.
I guess guy from HarvestGeek has a dream vacation for $47,053 and now back to the boring office life ;)
so excited... after over 2 years, and all these delays the product must be super perfect! no?
2 years 1 month late now... I'll be back next year to check on progress
What's wrong about suing this guy for committing fraud?
I like James idea, send out what hardware you have. You should then open source whatever software you have and let the community figure something out. Some communication would be great as well.
We have seen pictures of the hardware. It apparently exists. How about you send what you have out? This is ridiculous..
so thats it ? i put 319 dollars into this, waited 2 years, I'll never back anything again. thats just so dissapointing. Can i do anything?
I think he gave up on this project shortly after it got kickstarted. Such a shame. Hope he spent the money on something nice.
Delays are understandable, often inevitable. But the lack of updates and little to no reply to comments on here or on the forums is what is making people feel like there is no project. We have no proof you have actually 'done' anything. No photos, no videos, no examples of code. Just 5 updates a year on a project we successfully funded more than 2 years ago. I was more confident when you admitted you needed help on certain things, but nothing seems to have come of that, and I don't believe for a second there wouldn't have been many people of various skill sets wanting to help this project reach completion. Give us some real updates, send out the hardware (which should be finished by now as well), lets those who are able to, collaborate on the software/firmware side, or give us our money back.
Based on your last update, the only tasks left are software related. That is something an online community can build. So, why not send out the hardware?
If there is hardware related tasks needed I will offer some of my time to help out as I am a mechanical engineer.
There really should be an update by now..
It's now May, still no updates or any kind of indication that this project is even real. If you are just waiting on LCDs and software, ship the rest of the hardware. I would rather spend the £5 and solder my own LCD, and the software could be developed by the community. Somehow I doubt that will happen though...
Is there anything else we can do as backers aside from reporting this project to kickstarter?
Have you still not found any developers willing to help with your issues ?
you can at least release the source to the backers ( open source ) and ship out the PCBs that you had designed and manufactured.
You should have received the LCD modules that were blamed for a previous delay so there shouldn't be a reason not to ship what you have and we can at least get something more useful than an update every 4 months.
3 months since the last update. There must be something to report?...right?...
Guys, thought i might share this with the rest of the people who are chasing up dates. http://rayshobby.net/ospi/
the guy has a $100 hardware that controls standard sprinklers and the community has developed some great additional plugins.
Please post an update. Anything at all will do. Tell us what music you are listening to. Do you like the new Flat White drink at Starbucks? How's the weather. Anything. Really.
Mike, I reported this project to Kickstarter both with the button below and the link given by 'Dalmatoid' here in the comments.
This project becomes a joke and instead of making people think along the way with you on how to solve this, you get the opposite by not responding and apologizing, and not reaching any progress at all.
I have given you more than 2 years now to accomplish anything, without success.
Projects here on Kickstarter that are more complex and require even more skills and logistics have succeeded way faster, simply because they are led by people who know how to do so.
It seems to me this is a lost case because you miss both, skills and leadership.
As mentioned in the Kickstarter policy, I suggest you stop working on this project and starting working on a refund plan.
Any update for February?
I am still hopeful that this project will be successful. It sounds like the hardware is ready and that it is just the software that needs completing.
Is there any way to get hardware in the hands of users and let the community figure out any software updates that it needs?
What is the problem?
Is this a scam to keep dragging us along until we lose interest?
I backed you with quite a bit of money.
I would just like to have some straight answers.
Feels to me a year from now will be more excuses.
Hey, just got your apologetic update. We, your backers, backed you because we thought you had a cool idea. So...that makes us allies, albeit grumpy ones. And probably mad gardeners who understand that not every seed planted flowers. But we planted this seed with you because we thought it was a cool seed.
So you underbudgeted and overpromised. It happens, and I already mentioned the grumpy bit. You sound sincere, and I did already mention the grumpy bit, so moving past all that and assuming you are sincere about finishing...
What -- very specifically -- do you need to finish? Time? money? expertise?
Is there a -- very specific -- part of your vision you have finished and can deliver/sell/market/display as evidence that you are making real progress?
Can you call upon your backers for specific bits of work - expertise - cash to get this done so you can live the rest of your life with your head held high and we can get on with our gardening?
We need specificity. No one can help unless we understand the true gap.
Think micro-tasks. Think cooperation. Think getting it done.
Coming up to 2 years. Think we will something that works? I'm in deep. Very disappointed.
Ok guys, I just filed another complaint with Kickstarter. Everyone start doing this. This project failed and Mike scammed us. Everyone has to start filing complaints if we want some action to be undertaken.
"If your project is successfully funded, you are required to fulfill all rewards or refund any backer whose reward you do not or cannot fulfill. A failure to do so could result in damage to your reputation or even legal action on behalf of your backers..."
Mike, give an update on the project or send me my refund. Thanks...
Micheal doesn't seem to respond to messages on facebook or twitter or from the Harvestgeek website, He is active on Reddit under the username " wangyo " ,
Maybe we can pressure him to respond on the project status if enough of us contact him directly in public view to get him to fulfill the project deliverables or refund our contributions,this is really ridiculous !
Hello, any updates? I'm putting together an aquaponics project and would love to incorporate HarvestGeek into it so I'm hoping that it's ready for shipping soon.
@Mike what is going on?
@everyone who pledged: if we don't get some kind of info SOON we all have to file complaints with Kickstarter. I sent them an e-mail allready and they replied some generic crap about some projects taking longer than expected bla bla (I'm fine with delays) I'm not fine with Mike not responding. I think we got screwed and we need to take action. Everyone file complaints and request you money back. Mike had an obligation! He did not fullfill it!
Any updates since the move? Is this project still a go?
I believe this project failed.
Please provide an update.
Also, if these do ship soon, you should send out requests for shipping addresses for those that have moved, like myself. I do not think what you have in your records reflects my current address. Thanks
Any new updates? It seemed like things were moving forward with the last update in September?
"The cases and the LCD units are the last pieces were waiting for prior to assembly. The lead time the LCD mfr for those is end of October and will then probably take a couple weeks to be couriered. "
So is this realistic or not? If so, you should have those LCD's in hand now.