Use this space to cheer the creator along, ask questions, and talk to your fellow backers. Please remember to be respectful and considerate. Thanks!
Where are the "more frequent updates"???
you will get an email to confirm your address...
I read you wrote we should post on kickstarter for address change confirmation, as it's been 3 years... Where should we send the current address information?
OK, so I spent some time with Dylan on Saturday night and we talked a bit about the Kickstarter. He's really conscious about how it's gone and the delays; the simple answer is that he hadn't really considered just how time consuming it would all be outside of the music. Very apologetic and, as per the last updates, he is just going to ship everything out as soon as it turns up (which should start soon). There should also be more frequent updates too.
Unfortunately I forgot to ask about address confirmation.
And I think we all deserve a little extra goodie ... for our patience ...
I'll get excited when I get the stuff ... this whole thing (incl. Kickstarter & their way of support) is a mess ... I'm happy when it's done.
Ye of little faith...
I don't want to act like the others - I understand them though.
An update would be appropriate.
@RemiA ... a shitstorm???
All the people who supported this "project" should contact Kickstarter ...
there must be something we can do? is my hard earned money flushed down the toilet with this bulls**t project!!!?!?
this is also my last kickstarter project! There is absolut NO support from their side! And Mr. Carlson...hm...I tried to contact him through FB but it seems that the message function is OFF now. I left a message at his main site
This is just getting ridiculous. I've lost a lot of respect for Dylan Carlson with this thing as I cannot think of a worse thing to do than take the people that care for your music for a ride. I certainly will not support him in the future. As for Kickstarter.. Never again.
? ? ? N E W S ? ? ?
I can just laugh (like a weirdo...)...
Yes, some news would ne nice. But I doubt there will be any.....
Heeeey ... an aswer by Dylan through FB:
currently awaiting test copies from the vinyl pressing plant. I'll be sending out a more detailed update via kickstarter once we have those.
thanks for your continued patience.
Travis here with Kickstarter support--thanks for reaching out and taking the time to bring this to our attention.
We do our best to give project creators the freedom and support necessary to bring their new and exciting ideas to life. This often means that when projects launch on Kickstarter they’re in the early stages of development. While we encourage creators to communicate regularly through this process, it’s important to remember that each of them will approach this differently. In most cases, this may be the first time that a creator has the responsibility of communicating with a large support community. Still, we expect that creators will make every effort to complete their project as promised and keep backers updated along the way. We also hope that backers will remain understanding as everyone learns through this process.
I’ve reached out to this creator and offered our assistance. My goal is to open the lines of communication and encourage them to update more effectively moving forward. You should continue reaching out to them on your end as well. Through this joint effort, we’ll be reminding the creator to check in.
Thanks for being a thoughtful backer and member of the Kickstarter community. I hope you hear more from the project creator soon.
I contacted KICKSTARTER again.
What's happen ????? more than three years without informations, any release .....
WHEN THIS F....... PROJECT WILL BE ON AIR
KICKSTARTER = first time and never again
@RemiA ... yeah, it seems so :( I tried to contact Mr. Carlson through different channels ... NO response!
@Sven : they can't do anything, are not liable for anything etc...
I'm wondering that Kickstarter is doing nothing about this situation...
I never thought it would come down to this, but is there any way to get my money back?
@Jarkko ... he didn't even read it until now �
@Sven....Did he answer?
I sent him a message through his FB-account.
This whole project became a joke ... I still can't believe it.
Have the ghastly impression that I will never get to the finished product. Love Dylan and his work but this is just not cool.
So we're now three years down the line and this album shows no sign of appearing.
What's more, according to Discogs there have been no less than 9 releases by Dylan/Earth since this project was funded:
La Strega And The Cunning Man In The Smoke (2012)
Edward Kelley's Blues (2012)
Modern English Folklore Volume One: Hackney (2012)
Angels Of Darkness, Demons Of Light II (2012)
Holly's Jeans (2013)
Elephanto Bianco (2014)
Primitive And Deadly (2014)
Boa / Cold (2014)
Sorry ... I have to do it:
...THREE (!3!) YEARS...���
Wow...just three weeks to go...then we have completed 3(!!!) YEARS (!!!) since funding! THIS IS DISGUSTING! Is this a Guns n Roses - project???
Earth eurotour starting soon... Any news about this project? Thanks.
U P D A T E or FINAL PRODUCT ... please!
I also tried to get the Gold download key - no joy. Heading for 3 years since funding and no updates. Not good Dylan is clearly busy with Earth but it would be nice to think we might get something for our investment one day.
@Jarkko ... UPDATE ? ... What does this word mean? Arrgh ...
Am I a bad 'fan' if I dare to ask for an UPDATE!??
Estimate delivery May 2013
In addition to the dead email provided here on kickstarter, I directly emailed EARTH's management about the GOLD download. No response. I also inquired about the promised EARTH/Dylan Carlson tickets for a local show. Again, no response. This is a heavy bummer.
Here is his answer:
"[...] will be putting finishing touches on it as soon as the tour is over"
I wrote Mr. Carlson through his instagram-account. Hopefully I will get a response! This is my third kickstarter-project ... and my last!
michael murray - yes, i saw that after searching on here... so i emailed him and guess what?... yeah, ive got no reply.... there's someone else further down this comment list that says the same and that was weeks ago... man, yknow... this project goal was reached in feb 2012. its now september 2014.... when i pledged swans with their 'my father will' album to be made, i got updates regularly, and the thing was completed within the timespan. Mr Carlson just lost himself a fan.
Awesome...actually there is one EARTH-new per day on Facebook ... but NO update in here since may ... not bad ...
I used to be a massive fan of Earth...
Pete Brooks, The download was mentioned in the last update #55, it says
"If you wish a digital copy please email firstname.lastname@example.org and you will be emailed a code to download the album on release day."
As far as shipping address goes, the very first email sent out when originally backing this states
"When your reward is ready, Dylan Carlson will send you a survey via email to request any info needed to deliver your reward (mailing address, t-shirt size, etc)."
I don't imagine it would be very likely that Dylan would just hope for the best and send them straight out to the addresses he got back then without checking with people first.
Pete Brooks ... I'm with you... these lack of updates is ... pfffff ... to wait for already paid product this long is hilarious!