Lessons from a Floundering Kickstarter Project

Share this post

Earlier today I got an email from a man named David Lang linking to a blog post he had written called Lessons From a Floundering Kickstarter Project. In it, David discusses his project The Great Mate Journey, which has raised $240 in its first 30 days, 10% of its total. He’s disappointed in its performance thus far, and his post offers an extremely frank assessment of why he thinks that’s true. It’s a must-read for everyone.

The post is striking because of its honesty — it takes courage to be open about potential failure. And despite his pessimism, David’s project can still make it — it would not surprise me in the least. His project just needs to catch a spark, and there’s no telling how or when that could happen.

Regardless of how it turns out, his advice could not be better for people starting their projects. We asked David if we could share the post here, and he graciously agreed. Here is David’s post, in full:

As I write this, my Kickstarter project is half way through the funding period. Unfortunately, I’m nowhere near half way to my funding goal, in fact I haven’t even raised 10 percent of my goal. I’ve basically given up hope that I will be able to reach my stated goal, which is fine. I’m still going ahead with my idea but now I need to figure out another way to fund it. I’ll raid my 401k if need be, this damn thing is going to happen! At this point, I figure the best thing I can do is share some lessons from a failing project so future Kickstarters can avoid making the same mistakes. Kind of like donating my body to science.

1) Have a Good Idea. This seems like a no brainer, but it’s worth noting anyway. My project, the “Great Maté Journey” seemed like a great idea to me: I could give some meaning and purpose to my travels to South America, I could learn a ton about my favorite drink, I could share my journey with other maté drinkers who were thinking about making a similar trip, I could educate people about the health benefits of maté and maté drinking, etc. I thought I had it figured out. I actually ran the idea by a few friends and they told me it was a cool idea. There’s only one thing I forgot to take into account: NOBODY CARES. Well, that’s not completely true, my parents kind of care. But for the most part, nobody gives a crap what you want to do. Most people will only take interest in things that will help them, or help them help others. It’s not about me (or you), it’s about helping people. I have every intention of using my trip for the greater good, but I didn’t do a great job of conveying that message. Successful projects make other peoples lives better, they give their contributors a warm and fuzzy feeling. Crappy projects don’t.

2) Be Honest. It’s so easy to spot something unauthentic. Everybody knows when you’re not telling the truth (or even the whole truth). Every human being, whether they know it or not, has a built-in bullshit detector and nobody is going to contribute to something that isn’t from the heart. A reader will always forgive a storyteller that over-exaggerates a story, it makes it more interesting. However, it’s impossible to keep a reader enthralled when you hold back any of the truth. With my project, I definitely want to learn everything I can about maté, but I also want to ride horses with the Gauchos in Patagonia, see Iguazu Falls, practice my Spanish, learn the tango, and fall in love with a beautiful Argentinian woman. That’s the whole story.  I guarantee it will make for a better story, and I probably should have just explained it that way from the beginning. The maté is important, but it needs to be a part of a bigger story.

3) Set a Realistic Goal. “Oh cool, here’s a way to raise money for my big idea! Now if everyone I know just donates $5 then I can raise {Insert overly ambitious goal here}” I think this was what I was thinking when I started my project. I bet this is what all the other failed project were thinking, too. It’s natural to want to throw the total project cost as your goal, but it might not be the best strategy. Crowd-funding is really cool, but it’s really new. You can’t expect it to fund the whole project (it might, but don’t count on it.) I think a better mentality for my project was to use Kickstarter as a small victory. Something that showed I could get a moderate level of interest in my project. I should have set the bar lower and then easily reached my goal. After receiving the Kickstarter support, I could have gone for sponsorship from a maté company, or pitched the story to a magazine or newspaper. There are a ton of ways to get more funding, don’t expect crowd-funding to do it all. Instead, think of Kickstarter as a springboard of support for bigger things.

4) Don’t Count on Your Friends. I mean, of course count on your friends, just not to support your Kickstarter project. I showed a friend of mine the project in person on his computer while I was working on it, in order to get his opinion.

“Very cool, I’ll probably donate at the $50 level.”

“Nice!” I thought. Turns out that was the worst thing he could have said. Not only did he never donate, but he totally over-inflated my expectations about what I could raise. And what am I going to say, it’s hard to bug people for money that they said they would donate. It puts a weird tension on the friendship. It took me three weeks of bothering my brother to get him to finally donate. As a general rule, take everyone you think would definitely contribute and multiply that by 5%. The real gains are made by getting people you don’t know to contribute, which brings me to the next lesson…

5) Have a Marketing Plan. What separates your project from the rest of the pack at Kickstarter? How are people going to find your project? I put a lot of time into my video and write up for my project. I’ve spent a lot of time writing blog posts (including this!) and talking to people about the project. I didn’t spend nearly enough time on a marketing plan. I’ve only recently started using Twitter Search to find people who are interested in maté, I think that’s a start. I think successful projects do this well. In order to get your project to the finish line, expect to spend more time on marketing than you do on content. Don’t skimp on content, but expect to spend a lot more time on marketing.

I really hope this message is helpful for someone and that no one else makes the same humiliating mistakes as I have. I wish I would’ve read it before I started my project. If you want to see what remains of a failing Kickstarter project, check out www.greatmatejourney.com (Pity donations are gratefully accepted.)

Good luck on your project!

Comments
    1. Daniel McGuire on

      Thanks for the honesty.

    2. Missing avatar

      Randy Knuth on

      Thanks for pointing out where the land mines are!

    3. Erick Good on

      Mate is stupid. But you seem smart.

    4. Lydia Diaz on

      Thank you for writing and sharing this blog! Definitely reenergized me to market more!

    5. Carl Davis on

      Thanks for the insight! Best of luck on your next project!

    6. Lori Watts on

      Sorta wish I had read this before I launched...but then I might never have launched at all.

    7. Missing avatar

      deleted on

      This user's account has been deleted.

    8. art swenson on

      MARKETing.... where, who ,how, and when ? Here? "President Aaron Burr steals the election of 1800" an Alternative Historical drama(and a running story of romance,political and emotional) to be a eBook on Amazon's kindle......http://exoterrenegardens.webs.com

    9. Morris DuBose III on

      This is an amazingly frank piece. Thank you for the value added

    10. Missing avatar

      Kollin Donovan on

      I was also inspired by this one. I face some marketing issues while working for http://assignmentjedii.co.uk/dissertation-help/ but this really makes a difference for me.

    11. Missing avatar

      jaaduu on

      play cool math games on http://coolmath-mathgames.com
      more math games on http://coolmath-mathgames.net
      pbs kids games on http://pbskids-games.net
      and finally cool math games run 3 http://coolmathgames-run.com

Line icon alert icon Artboard Copy 8 arrow-down icon arrow-down arrow-left icon arrow-left arrow-point-left icon Fill 1 Copy 5 arrow-point-right icon Fill 1 arrow-right icon arrow-right arrow-up-right icon icon--arrow-up-right copy bar-chart icon Artboard Copy 6 bell icon Combined Shape Copy 5 book icon Artboard Copy 3 bookmark icon Fill 1 brand-assets icon Artboard Copy 13 cart icon Artboard Copy 4 chat icon chat check icon Fill 1 Copy 6 circle-back icon Fill 1 Copy 13 circle-forward icon Fill 1 Copy 16 circle-k icon circle-k circle-left icon circle-left circle-right icon circle-right clipboard icon Artboard Copy 12 clock icon Combined Shape close icon close closed-caption icon Fill 1 compass icon Combined Shape Copy 2 conversion icon conversion delta-down icon Fill 1 delta-left icon delta-right icon Fill 1 delta-up icon Fill 1 duplicate icon duplicate embed icon Combined Shape Copy 6 eye icon Combined Shape Copy 12 facebook-contained icon Facebook Contained facebook icon Facebook logo flag icon Fill 1 Copy 3 gear icon Fill 1 Copy 14 global-africa icon Fill 1 Copy 9 global-america icon Fill 1 Copy 10 global-asia icon Fill 1 Copy 17 graph-bar icon Combined Shape Copy 9 graph-line icon Combined Shape Copy 16 heart icon Fill 1 Copy 8 help icon human icon icon--human icon--alarm icon icon--alarm icon--alert icon icon--alert icon--arrow-down icon icon--arrow-down icon--arrow-left icon icon--arrow-left icon--arrow-right icon icon--arrow-right icon--arrow-up-right icon icon--arrow-up-right icon--arrow-up icon icon--arrow-up icon--backer-badge icon icon--backer-badge icon--bell icon icon--bell icon--bolt icon icon--bolt icon--bookmark-outline icon icon--bookmark-outline icon--bookmark icon icon--bookmark icon--calculator icon icon--calculator icon--calendar-check icon icon--calendar-check icon--calendar icon icon--calendar icon--campaign-outline icon icon--campaign-outline icon--check icon icon--check icon--chevron-down icon icon--chevron-down icon--chevron-left icon icon--chevron-left icon--chevron-right icon icon--chevron-right icon--chevron-up icon icon--chevron-up icon--circle-around icon icon--circle-around icon--circle-back icon icon--circle-back icon--circle-forward icon icon--circle-forward icon--circle-loader icon Page 1 icon--circle icon icon--clipboard icon icon--clipboard icon--clock icon icon--clock icon--closed-caption icon icon--closed-caption icon--code icon icon--code icon--collapse icon icon--collapse icon--commissions icon icon--commissions icon--compass icon icon--compass icon--confirmation icon icon--confirmation icon--conversion icon icon-conversion icon--cpu icon icon--curve-right icon icon--curve-right icon--cross icon icon--cross icon--delta-down icon icon--delta-down icon--delta-left icon icon--delta-left icon--delta-right icon icon--delta-right icon--delta-up icon icon--delta-up icon--download icon icon--download icon--ellipsis icon icon--expand icon icon--expand icon--external icon icon--external icon--eye icon icon--eye icon--facebook icon icon--facebook icon--filter icon icon--filter icon--flag icon icon--flag icon--frown-filled icon icon--frown icon icon--gear icon icon--gear icon--globe-africa icon icon--globe-africa icon--globe-america icon icon--globe-america icon--globe-asia icon icon--globe-asia icon--graph-bar icon icon--graph-bar icon--graph-line icon icon--graph-line icon--happy-filled icon icon--happy icon icon--heart-outline icon icon--heart outline icon--heart-thin-outline icon Fill 1 icon--heart icon icon--heart icon--home icon icon--home icon--home-with-door icon icon--human icon icon--human icon--humans icon icon--humans icon--image icon icon--image icon--inbox icon icon--inbox icon--info icon icon--info icon--instagram icon icon/instagram icon--lightbulb icon icon--lightbulb icon--link icon icon--link icon--lock-black-bg icon lock-icon icon--lock icon icon--lock icon--mail icon icon--mail icon--meh-filled icon icon--meh icon icon--menu icon icon--menu icon--message icon icon--message icon--mobile icon icon--mobile icon--overflow icon icon--overflow icon--pause icon icon--pause icon--pencil icon icon--pencil icon--pin icon icon--pin icon--pinterest icon icon--pinterest icon--play icon icon--play icon--plus-human icon icon--plus-human icon--plus icon icon--plus icon--prohibit icon icon--prohibit icon--project-budget icon icon--pull-quote icon icon--pull-quote icon--question-filled icon icon--question-filled icon--question icon icon--question icon--reorder icon icon-reorder icon--reply icon icon--reply icon--save icon icon--save icon--saved icon icon--saved icon--search icon icon--search icon--section-break icon icon--section-break icon--small-k icon icon--sound-hi icon icon--sound-hi icon--sound-lo icon icon--sound-lo icon--sound-mute icon icon--sound-mute icon--star-outline icon Star Outline icon--star icon icon--star icon--subtitles-captions icon icon--subtitles-captions icon--text-bold icon icon--text-bold icon--text-bullet icon icon--text-bullet icon--text-italic icon icon--text-italic icon--textalign-centered icon icon--textalign-centered icon--textalign-right icon icon--textalign-right icon--thumbs-down icon icon--thumbs-down icon--thumbs-up icon icon--thumbs-up icon--thumbsdown-outline icon icon--thumbsdown-outline icon--thumbsup-outline icon icon--thumbsup-outline icon--trash icon icon--trash icon--tumblr icon icon--tumblr icon--twitter icon icon--twitter icon--unlink icon Artboard icon--unlock icon icon--unlock icon--update-freeform-round icon icon--update-freeform-round icon--update-freeform icon icon--update-freeform icon--update-pinned icon Artboard icon--update-qa-round icon icon--update-qa-round icon--update-qa icon icon--update-qa icon--upload icon icon--upload icon--video icon icon--video icon--youtube icon icon--youtube icon-imagealign-center icon icon-imagealign-center icon-imagealign-left icon icon-imagealign-left icon-imagealign-right icon icon-imagealign-right info icon Combined Shape Copy instagram icon instagram copy kickstarter icon Artboard Copy 5 leaf icon leaf lightbulb icon icon--lightbulb link icon Combined Shape Copy 8 loading-spin icon lock icon Combined Shape Copy 4 mail icon Combined Shape map-pin icon Fill 1 menu icon Group message icon Fill 1 Copy 12 mobile icon Page 1 Copy 2 pause icon pause copy pencil icon Combined Shape Copy 3 pin icon Combined Shape Copy 11 pinterest icon pinterest play icon play copy plus-human icon icon--plus-human plus icon Fill 1 Copy 7 question icon Combined Shape Copy 14 search icon Fill 1 Copy 11 shapeshift icon share icon Fill 1 Copy slash icon solid-arrow icon solid-arrow sound-hi icon Combined Shape sound-lo icon Combined Shape sound-mute icon Combined Shape star icon Fill 1 Copy 2 stopwatch icon Group 2 thumbs-up icon Shape tools icon Shape trash icon Combined Shape tumblr icon tumblr copy twitter icon twitter copy user icon Artboard Copy 10 volume-up icon Artboard Copy 9 warning icon Combined Shape Copy 10 write icon Artboard Copy 11 x icon Fill 1 Copy 4 youtube icon Combined Shape