Guest Post: Martha Shane on Kickstarting Without a Niche (or a Phone Dock)

Share this post

Project image

Since 2007 filmmakers Dan Nuxoll and Martha Shane have been chasing Marie Castaldo — convicted criminal, alleged con-artist, and scandal-plagued film fest director. As featured in the Wall Street Journal among other outlets, this Queens International Film Festival queen of con is one for the film history books! Nuxoll has spent the past decade as Rooftop Films' Program Director (among wearing many other festival and producer/composer/sound designer hats), and Shane is the Brooklyn-based documentary co-director, producer, and co-editor of Bi the Way (SXSW 2008 Official Selection), as well as the director of two more feature docs currently in post-production.

At the time that I’m writing this, my co-director Dan Nuxoll and I are two days away from the end of our Kickstarter campaign for The Mystery of Marie Jocelyne, a feature documentary about a convicted con artist who ran film festivals and film companies in the US for over twenty years. We have $1,500 left to raise to meet our goal of $22,880, so we thought this might be a good time to share a bit about our experience with this unusual project. 

Going into this, I knew one thing for sure: Kickstarter campaigns can be stressful. I have often found myself lying awake at night wondering how we are going to pull this off. But at the same time, I’ve always felt certain that this story is too entertaining and too unbelievable not to be told.

In the past, I’ve been part of teams that raised funds for Bi the Way, a feature documentary about bisexuality in America, and After Tiller, a documentary that follows four abortion doctors in the years after the murder of their close friend and colleague Dr. George Tiller. Fundraising for both of those projects had and has its own challenges, but with The Mystery of Marie Jocelyne, the question is more pronounced: Without a niche audience that the film can specifically appeal to, where, and how, do we find our supporters? 

Looking for inspiration, we started researching. There have been a number of documentaries (like Minecraft the Story of Mojang and My Reincarnation) that have raised a tremendous amount of money on Kickstarter, but most of those projects had an advantage over ours — they were docs that already had a clear built-in audience, or they were films that addressed specific political or social issues. Our documentary, on the other hand, is about a woman who is a convicted con artist. Though there are communities online that care a lot about fraud, not too many of those people are the type to give online credit card donations to people they don’t know (though that doesn’t mean we didn’t try to reach out to them!). So, given that, how could we convince people who didn’t already know about us and our movie to care enough about the project to make a donation? 

We looked around at some of the other hugely successful campaigns that weren’t documentaries. You have probably read about the off-the-charts success of the Elevation iPhone Dock, and the Double Fine Adventure video game. Perhaps these campaigns could offer inspiration? Maybe we could add some new rewards—like a Mystery of Marie Jocelyne iPod cable!

Then again, maybe not. It didn’t seem that there were many relevant lessons to be taken from these hugely successful campaigns. (Though, for the record, if we raise $2 million in the next two days, we’d be thrilled to create a Mystery of Marie Jocelyne video game, in addition to the documentary.)

Since people weren’t going to donate just because of our subject matter, we knew that we would really need to convey our vision for the film. Dan and I are confident that our film will be entertaining, suspenseful, hilarious, and thought-provoking, but that’s a little bit like a parent thinking their kid is smart, beautiful, charismatic, and definitely going to be President of the United States someday. We couldn’t just tell our audience that our film would be exciting and fun — we had to show them too. 

We had to figure out how tell this story in a way that would make it most compelling to the widest possible audience, and we had to figure it out now, before we were even finished shooting interviews. We had to learn how to compress the story of Marie — which spans multiple continents and the course of an entire lifetime — into a five-minute pitch. And we had to learn how to talk about myriad crazy stories without getting bogged down in the many tangential details.

And in addition to telling the story concisely, we knew we had to spend a little bit more time on our video than some people do. We couldn’t sit in front of the camera and read the synopsis — we had to make our video dynamic enough that that audiences could get a sense of how our film would be different from other documentaries. And we did that by taking some stylistic chances, creating some fun graphics, and using music and pacing to create a sense of suspense and urgency.  

The wonderful thing is that doing this work for our campaign has helped us to tighten our vision for the movie and understand what we need to make the final film work. And that, I think, is the gift that Kickstarter has given us. Beyond providing a platform for us to raise money, it has forced us to learn how to talk about and promote the film in the most effective way possible. And that’s something that I would recommend for any documentary filmmaker who’s trying to tell a story that doesn’t fit into the usual categories. 

We still have a long way to go in the next day, and I’m still terrified. But that said, no matter how challenging it might seem to undertake a crowdfunding campaign when you’re not sure exactly what crowd you should be aiming for, my advice would be: figure out what excites you about the project, and then figure out how to communicate that in the best way possible.  

    1. Kevin on

      Thanks for the tips! I'm in the works of trying to launch a feature film, and wondering where my audience would be for it, and also thought, if only I had an iPod charger or phone accessory to sell. You really have to build a campaign around your film and sell it and pitch it as best you can to as many people as you can.

    2. Missing avatar

      deleted on

      This user's account has been deleted.

    3. Missing avatar

      Christy Hopkins on

      And even if you do know what crowd you're aiming for, the advice should be to figure out what excites you about the project and communicate that in the best way possible. Actually, maybe that is the relevant lesson to be taken from the hugely successful campaigns. Good luck to you.

    4. Walter Jeffries on

      I have been donating to a lot of different projects. Glad to see you reach your goal. I studied yours closely. I didn't donate to yours because, while there are certainly important lessons in the story, reading it left me with the sense that this project was a vendetta. That was a turn off. Perhaps some adjustment to the wording would help.

    5. BandedSociety US on

      Thats a really nice phone charger!

    6. Missing avatar

      Lloyd Claycomb on

      your article is the best..i really like to read this again!thanks

    7. Lake Street Films on

      Nice article! Its cool to know people when through the same process I'm going through and made it to the other side! I just launched my KS page and I'm thinking of all the things I can do to reach out to people. This has given me some nice advice on finding my project's niche. Thanks Martha!

    8. Ari Herstand on

      Great post! The video is really important. I ran a successful campaign raising $13,544 for my new album and explained how I did it on my music biz advice blog:…

    9. Missing avatar

      deleted on

      This comment has been removed by Kickstarter.

    10. Missing avatar

      deleted on

      This comment has been removed by Kickstarter.

    11. Missing avatar

      Namaku Keren on

      This comment has been removed by Kickstarter.

    12. Missing avatar

      Doa Ibu Tersayang on

      This comment has been removed by Kickstarter.

Line icon alert icon Artboard Copy 8 arrow-down icon arrow-down arrow-left icon arrow-left arrow-point-left icon Fill 1 Copy 5 arrow-point-right icon Fill 1 arrow-right icon arrow-right arrow-up-right icon icon--arrow-up-right copy bar-chart icon Artboard Copy 6 bell icon Combined Shape Copy 5 book icon Artboard Copy 3 bookmark icon Fill 1 brand-assets icon Artboard Copy 13 cart icon Artboard Copy 4 chat icon chat check icon Fill 1 Copy 6 circle-back icon Fill 1 Copy 13 circle-forward icon Fill 1 Copy 16 circle-k icon circle-k circle-left icon circle-left circle-right icon circle-right clipboard icon Artboard Copy 12 clock icon Combined Shape close icon close closed-caption icon Fill 1 compass icon Combined Shape Copy 2 conversion icon conversion delta-down icon Fill 1 delta-left icon delta-right icon Fill 1 delta-up icon Fill 1 duplicate icon duplicate embed icon Combined Shape Copy 6 eye icon Combined Shape Copy 12 facebook-contained icon Facebook Contained facebook icon Facebook logo flag icon Fill 1 Copy 3 gear icon Fill 1 Copy 14 global-africa icon Fill 1 Copy 9 global-america icon Fill 1 Copy 10 global-asia icon Fill 1 Copy 17 graph-bar icon Combined Shape Copy 9 graph-line icon Combined Shape Copy 16 heart icon Fill 1 Copy 8 help icon human icon icon--human icon--alarm icon icon--alarm icon--alert icon icon--alert icon--arrow-down icon icon--arrow-down icon--arrow-left icon icon--arrow-left icon--arrow-right icon icon--arrow-right icon--arrow-up-right icon icon--arrow-up-right icon--arrow-up icon icon--arrow-up icon--backer-badge icon icon--backer-badge icon--bell icon icon--bell icon--bolt icon icon--bolt icon--bookmark-outline icon icon--bookmark-outline icon--bookmark icon icon--bookmark icon--calculator icon icon--calculator icon--calendar-check icon icon--calendar-check icon--calendar icon icon--calendar icon--campaign-outline icon icon--campaign-outline icon--check icon icon--check icon--chevron-down icon icon--chevron-down icon--chevron-left icon icon--chevron-left icon--chevron-right icon icon--chevron-right icon--chevron-up icon icon--chevron-up icon--circle-around icon icon--circle-around icon--circle-back icon icon--circle-back icon--circle-forward icon icon--circle-forward icon--circle-loader icon Page 1 icon--circle icon icon--clipboard icon icon--clipboard icon--clock icon icon--clock icon--closed-caption icon icon--closed-caption icon--code icon icon--code icon--collapse icon icon--collapse icon--commissions icon icon--commissions icon--compass icon icon--compass icon--confirmation icon icon--confirmation icon--conversion icon icon-conversion icon--cpu icon icon--curve-right icon icon--curve-right icon--cross icon icon--cross icon--delta-down icon icon--delta-down icon--delta-left icon icon--delta-left icon--delta-right icon icon--delta-right icon--delta-up icon icon--delta-up icon--download icon icon--download icon--ellipsis icon icon--expand icon icon--expand icon--external icon icon--external icon--eye icon icon--eye icon--facebook icon icon--facebook icon--filter icon icon--filter icon--flag icon icon--flag icon--frown-filled icon icon--frown icon icon--gear icon icon--gear icon--globe-africa icon icon--globe-africa icon--globe-america icon icon--globe-america icon--globe-asia icon icon--globe-asia icon--graph-bar icon icon--graph-bar icon--graph-line icon icon--graph-line icon--happy-filled icon icon--happy icon icon--heart-outline icon icon--heart outline icon--heart-thin-outline icon Fill 1 icon--heart icon icon--heart icon--home icon icon--home icon--home-with-door icon icon--human icon icon--human icon--humans icon icon--humans icon--image icon icon--image icon--inbox icon icon--inbox icon--info icon icon--info icon--instagram icon icon/instagram icon--lightbulb icon icon--lightbulb icon--link icon icon--link icon--lock-black-bg icon lock-icon icon--lock icon icon--lock icon--mail icon icon--mail icon--meh-filled icon icon--meh icon icon--menu icon icon--menu icon--message icon icon--message icon--mobile icon icon--mobile icon--overflow icon icon--overflow icon--pause icon icon--pause icon--pencil icon icon--pencil icon--pin icon icon--pin icon--pinterest icon icon--pinterest icon--play icon icon--play icon--plus-human icon icon--plus-human icon--plus icon icon--plus icon--prohibit icon icon--prohibit icon--project-budget icon icon--pull-quote icon icon--pull-quote icon--question-filled icon icon--question-filled icon--question icon icon--question icon--reorder icon icon-reorder icon--reply icon icon--reply icon--save icon icon--save icon--saved icon icon--saved icon--search icon icon--search icon--section-break icon icon--section-break icon--small-k icon icon--sound-hi icon icon--sound-hi icon--sound-lo icon icon--sound-lo icon--sound-mute icon icon--sound-mute icon--star-outline icon Star Outline icon--star icon icon--star icon--subtitles-captions icon icon--subtitles-captions icon--text-bold icon icon--text-bold icon--text-bullet icon icon--text-bullet icon--text-italic icon icon--text-italic icon--textalign-centered icon icon--textalign-centered icon--textalign-right icon icon--textalign-right icon--thumbs-down icon icon--thumbs-down icon--thumbs-up icon icon--thumbs-up icon--thumbsdown-outline icon icon--thumbsdown-outline icon--thumbsup-outline icon icon--thumbsup-outline icon--trash icon icon--trash icon--tumblr icon icon--tumblr icon--twitter icon icon--twitter icon--unlink icon Artboard icon--unlock icon icon--unlock icon--update-freeform-round icon icon--update-freeform-round icon--update-freeform icon icon--update-freeform icon--update-pinned icon Artboard icon--update-qa-round icon icon--update-qa-round icon--update-qa icon icon--update-qa icon--upload icon icon--upload icon--video icon icon--video icon--youtube icon icon--youtube icon-imagealign-center icon icon-imagealign-center icon-imagealign-left icon icon-imagealign-left icon-imagealign-right icon icon-imagealign-right info icon Combined Shape Copy instagram icon instagram copy kickstarter icon Artboard Copy 5 leaf icon leaf lightbulb icon icon--lightbulb link icon Combined Shape Copy 8 loading-spin icon lock icon Combined Shape Copy 4 mail icon Combined Shape map-pin icon Fill 1 menu icon Group message icon Fill 1 Copy 12 mobile icon Page 1 Copy 2 pause icon pause copy pencil icon Combined Shape Copy 3 pin icon Combined Shape Copy 11 pinterest icon pinterest play icon play copy plus-human icon icon--plus-human plus icon Fill 1 Copy 7 question icon Combined Shape Copy 14 search icon Fill 1 Copy 11 shapeshift icon share icon Fill 1 Copy slash icon solid-arrow icon solid-arrow sound-hi icon Combined Shape sound-lo icon Combined Shape sound-mute icon Combined Shape star icon Fill 1 Copy 2 stopwatch icon Group 2 thumbs-up icon Shape tools icon Shape trash icon Combined Shape tumblr icon tumblr copy twitter icon twitter copy user icon Artboard Copy 10 volume-up icon Artboard Copy 9 warning icon Combined Shape Copy 10 write icon Artboard Copy 11 x icon Fill 1 Copy 4 youtube icon Combined Shape