Hi everyone,
I want to update you on three things:
- Shipping status of Stylus Caps
- An issue that we had with shipping and how we fixed it
- A brief overview of the tips
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
SHIPPING STATUS
The only orders that have been shipped are to US based Backers at the following levels:
- $20 Stainless Backers who pre-ordered Stylus Caps for Sharpie or Fineliner
- $25 Brass Backers who pre-ordered Stylus Caps for Fineliner
Here's a handy chart to know where your order stands.
Orders sent out were determined by what Stylus Cap metal bodies we had on hand. If we had it, we shipped it. We're still waiting for the Bic Stylus Caps to be finished, so none of the Packs (Stainless, Brass, Both, or Studio) have been sent out.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
THE SHIPPING ISSUE - and - HOW WE FIXED IT
12 days ago, I started getting a few reports of Backers who had packages that arrived with their packages open and their Stylus Caps missing. After five or so Backers reported the same issue, I stopped all shipping to fix the problem.
The problem came down to the seals. They simply were not big enough to hold up to the heat and humidity of the last week of August. Sitting on a hot metal truck loosened the glue and with one good drop, the box could come open and the Stylus Cap would pop out. We obviously tested the package prior to shipping, but it was on a much smaller scale and the sealing issue did not occur.
Out of the 564 orders we sent out, 33 Backers had this packaging issue. That comes to 5.8%. The other 94.2% successfully received their Stylus Caps. For a first run product, using a first run fulfillment center (my parents dining room table), and a brand new box, this seems pretty good to me. Not ideal to be sure, but in the grand scheme of things acceptable as long as its fixable.
The fix is simple: Larger seals and more of them. The seals are now double the size (up from 0.75in to 1.5in) and we use two extra seals on the sides of the box. This dramatically increases the rigidity of the package. We sent 10 test packs out with the new seals to Backers who had missing Stylus Caps (including one to myself in Chicago so I could see it in action) and all 11 successfully received their packages with Stylus Caps. Backers that had the problem have been in direct contact with me and will be receiving new Stylus Caps at no charge. I feel that this issue has now been resolved.
If you have additional thoughts or pictures you want to send me regarding the packaging, please don't hesitate to get in touch with me.
At this point you may be wondering why I care so much about a box.
1) It uses less material than the typical shipping box.
Think about the brown shipping box that usually shows up at your door. That box usually has another box, the actual product's box, inside of that. This design eliminates the brown box by making the product's box shippable.
2) It uses less space than the typical shipping box.
Imagine that same brown box and all the wasted space, or "air" that usually surrounds the inner box. Air matters when you look at fuel consumption. The more product you can get on a truck, the more efficiently you are using that truck, the less fuel you are wasting.
3) Its nicer than the typical shipping box.
At the end of the day, when someone receive their Stylus Cap, I want them to know that thought and care that went into their Stylus Cap went into every aspect around it. The box that it shipped in, the way that it was purchased, the customer service, the reduced use of fuel and materials, etc.
I think that this stuff matters and that people want it to matter. This is the level of care I want to put into everything that MORE/REAL does. It's worth it to me to work hard at getting it right, even if we don't completely get it right the first time. Thanks for giving us the opportunity to try and get it right.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
THE TIPS
I have been avidly reading the reports though Kickstarter, email, Tweets, as well as communicating directly with Backers who have received their Stylus Caps. The early reviews essentially boils down to this: either people are in love with their Stylus Caps or they think they are unusable due to the friction between the tips and the glass screen. The split is about 60% love / 40% unusable tips. There seems to be nowhere in between.
I tested the tips fairly throughly prior to sending them out and felt pretty good about the overall quality, including the friction. After getting a few reports of Backers with friction issues, I tested a few tips from the production run and noticed that they were indeed a bit grippier than when I first received them. I have a few theories as to why this happened and have been working with a chemical engineer to make adjustments. But for now, there are a couple of interesting things I am learning out of this:
1) A good deal of people like these slightly grippy tips. If I had to relate the feel of using the current production tips to another drawing tool, it would be oil pastels. Oil pastels are sort of like an artist's crayon and they too have a slightly grippy feel when you use them. When you use oil pastels you generally draw at a slower, more deliberate pace.
I showed the tips to Marty Thaler a week ago. Marty is a professor at the IIT Institute of Design here in Chicago, former IDEO design lead, all around nice guy. We started talking about the act of drawing. One of the points that he brought up was that drawing makes you concentrate on what you are thinking about on and gives you time to reflect. Slowing that act down can improve the quality of drawing. The slightly grippy tips help with this.
I think the larger insight, which is very exciting, is there is room for two types of tips: a "fast" tip and a "slow" tip. It's something I never would have thought of even a month ago, but I think is very exciting and will lead to more personalized solutions.
2) The idea of a Stylus Cap and the overall execution is still really well liked. In almost every case in which people tell me they don't like the friction of the tips, they quickly add "But I love everything else." The build quality of the cap, the engraving, the way it feels in your hand, but most importantly the idea of Stylus Caps themselves, are all really good things.
This is super encouraging to me. We're on the right track, there is just more work to be done.
So before we start shipping again, I would like to focus a little more time on the tips. There may be a chance to decrease the friction with the current parts I have on hand, or it might take a new design altogether. But before I make that call, I would like to hold out shipping any more orders on the off chance that something can indeed be done with the current tips. I'll update you when I have more to say about this.
If you have any questions in the meantime, I'm serious, don't hesitate to get in touch with me. I love talking with Backers and I try to respond as quickly as possible.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
THE BIG PICTURE
I will admit I was a bit bummed out the first day or so after some people started having problems. Since December, I've been throwing everything I have into to making Stylus Caps a reality. I put on average 12 hours into this every weekday and at least 4 hours every weekend day (and this is not my only job). I'm trying to prove that tech products can be developed not just in the US, but near my hometown. That thinking locally and using materials in a minimal way can have great sustainable benefits. That applying a designer's mind to every aspect of a production can lead to great stuff.
What snapped me out of it was getting back into the flow of what I think I do best: solving design problems, coming up with new plans, figuring stuff out. All these new ideas came to me about how to make Stylus Caps the best stylus I possibly can. There is no end point to this product or any product.
I'm not making any money on this project. I'm not selling it anywhere else (yet). I'm all in on getting it made for you. And hell, for me too. Wanting a Stylus Cap for myself is what started this whole thing.
Step back and realize how much has been accomplished. When I first came to you in mid-February, Stylus Caps were nothing more than some renderings, a couple of prototypes, and a plan of action in case the project took off. Here we are just 7 months later: factories are cranking out parts, boxes are printed, a few orders have been fulfilled. This is how products get off the ground. Its agonizing, unpredictable, timelines slip, you don't go to bed until 3am, and you lose sleep worrying if the spacing of the font on the engraving is wrong. But ultimately its one of the best experiences you can go through. I'm lucky I get to share it all with you.
Talk to you soon,
Don
ps. I thought you should see some of the stuff people have been doing with their Stylus Caps. So freakin' cool! Thanks for sharing your work.