Kickstarter

Comments

1. 1. 

      Creator Josef Platil on August 9, 2012

      Good evil

   2. 

      Creator Drew Summersett on August 7, 2012

      I'd say evil. As I'm sure has been pointed out before, going good then good is a dorky and very overdone theme. Although, going good then evil is a potentially awesome twist that is very under-looked... But anyway, more people tend to go good, and evil-then-good is a more interesting two-book premise than good-then-good, but not as good as a good-then-evil, and about even with evil-then-evil.

      ... Yeah.

   3. 

      Creator Natalie Charlesworth on August 4, 2012

      Actually, if there's a possibility of change later in the book, it would be intriguing to find out why you've turned evil- do you dice roll for a reason? Are you actually undercover with some villains and not letting the reader know until later? Evil but open-ended.

   4. 

      Creator Kickstarters on August 4, 2012

      EVIL!

      As people said before me, it's hard to decide without knowing the ends, but: With a good end, another good end is lame, while the hero turning evil is interesting (again, as it was pointed out). So you don't have much choice.

      With the evil end, it is intriguing to see a turn towards good (though maybe somewhat cheesy), but the possibility to turn even worse is also great to see!

      Thus, the evil end is the more interesting one for future decisions.

   5. 

      Creator Dane Turner on August 3, 2012

      I have liked the ideas of having both available as starting points. I know it'd probably be more work, but it would also be something new and amazing!

   6. 

      Creator Freuni on August 3, 2012

      It's hard to choose without having experienced the adventure before. But I would say... good, so that we can have another sequel when the hero will finally become evil.

   7. 

      Creator Andrew DeLong on August 3, 2012

      Evil - but for good reasons. I find that villains are almost always more interesting than heroes if they have good reasons for doing bad stuff, particularly when driven by largely selfless and morally justified goals - they're bad guys and they know it, but they have a cause that many might be sympathetic with (if not the manner that it's carried out). This also presents two paths where one could focus on a morally justified evil and the other on a more selfish evil. Looking forward to it either way you go.

   8. 

      Creator Emily Cobbs on August 2, 2012

      Good

   9. 

      Creator MC-3PO on August 2, 2012

      Evil, with the understanding that the success of an Evil book will ensure the creation of a Good book.

   10. 

       Creator John Brewer on August 1, 2012

       You should have two sequels, one for each path. You can box them as a trilogy, just like LOTR.

   11. 

       Creator Aaron on August 1, 2012

       Evil

   12. 

       Creator Joseph Bonaldi on August 1, 2012

       well evil but bad at it!

   13. 

       Creator Joseph Bonaldi on August 1, 2012

       Evil!

   14. 

       Creator foracoffee on August 1, 2012

       Good!

   15. 

       Creator Kelly Brown on August 1, 2012

       Good!

   16. 

       Creator Dan Ambrose on August 1, 2012

       Good!!

   17. 

       Creator Nikolas Lutton on August 1, 2012

       evil

   18. 

       Creator barna83 on July 31, 2012

       EVIL path, we should turn. :-)

   19. 

       Creator Nick on July 31, 2012

       I vote good.

   20. 

       Creator Deno on July 31, 2012

       Voting for good!

   21. 

       Creator Michael Danger Benningfield on July 31, 2012

       Voting Evil

   22. 

       Creator Seb on July 31, 2012

       Eeeevil >:D

   23. 

       Creator Kathrin Brogli on July 31, 2012

       Good!

   24. 

       Creator Bryan Roach on July 31, 2012

       Good! Like log.

       It's log, log, it's big, it's heavy, it's wood!
       It's log, log, it's better than bad, it's good!

       (Yep, I was just checking out John K's kickstarter.)

   25. 

       Creator Ryan Belden on July 31, 2012

       Evil. EEEVVVIIILLL...

   26. 

       Creator Jayson Utz on July 31, 2012

       Good

   27. 

       Creator Prakash Raman on July 30, 2012

       Good

   28. 

       Creator Zane on July 30, 2012

       Good

   29. 

       Creator Ilya Medvedev on July 30, 2012

       Evil.

   30. 

       Creator May-Li Seah on July 30, 2012

       good please

   31. 

       Creator Rob Keleher on July 30, 2012

       Evil. I think you could do something new with a villian who struggles with his inner goodness. As opposed to a falling from grace, a rising from the depths?

   32. 

       Creator Steve(121234) Campbell on July 30, 2012

       Good, simply because good is often more involving where evil tends to be quirky but detaching.

   33. 

       Creator Bevin Cheng on July 30, 2012

       Good. Simply because I always try to be good on my first playthrough.

   34. 

       Creator Faokryn on July 30, 2012

       I personally would love to see a book in which the first page directs you to either an evil starting place or a good starting place. However, having to choose between the two, I would vote for good, with the hope that you would get around to making the evil version of the second book sometime in the future.

   35. 

       Creator Joseph Steven Heath on July 30, 2012

       EVIL!

   36. 

       Creator Kwaarp on July 30, 2012

       Wherever it starts, good or evil, I'd definitely like the option to change somewhere along the moral axis during the course of the book. Starting with good might be a better idea, since people tend to gravitate towards good anyway, but personally I'd really like to see what happens when villainy becomes a default.

       Short answer is evil, I guess.

   37. 

       Creator Steven Carrie on July 30, 2012

       Is there a KickStarter survey for how to vote or is it just a comment here?

       My vote is Good, although I agree Evil can be fun and I assume it would be written humourosly. I'd like to see both followon books made in the end. It will be easier to decide after playing the first book. :)

   38. 

       Creator Daniel Kerr on July 30, 2012

       If I have to choose one, it is good.

       I like TheNevin suggestion of a dual starting point and choices along the way would turn further in to evil or good.

   39. 

       Creator Lee Bougourd on July 30, 2012

       At the risk of seeming boring and obvious I must vote for good. However entertaining being evil can be, ultimately one should aspire to goodness in all things. (Ooh, sounds a bit preachy, though I don't mean it to be.)

   40. 

       Creator Khellar on July 30, 2012

       Evil!

   41. 

       Creator TheNevin on July 30, 2012

       I vote for good.
       (If you want to mix the choices, though, it should be doable: With the Paranoia-style vibe I'm expecting, you can just put 2 starting points in the second book, and have the reader end up doing mostly the same things no matter what path they intended to take.)

   42. 

       Creator Hugo Pipping on July 30, 2012

       How to decide without knowing much... It depends all on how the sequel tackles it.
       Being pure good or evil is always boring in and of itself, it's when you can't untangle the two that things get tense and interesting.
       Knowing myself I'll probably still pick the Good ending when I get there, so in the end I'll vote for:

       Good

   43. 

       Creator John Mahoney on July 30, 2012

       Good

   44. 

       Creator Jonathon Philip Chambers on July 29, 2012

       Hey! If you have both starts, tangle them, and allow good the opportunity to turn evil and evil the opportunity to turn good, that would be awesome!

   45. 

       Creator Rob Morris on July 29, 2012

       Reluctantly Evil!

   46. 

       Creator Jonathon Philip Chambers on July 29, 2012

       Split the difference. I tire easily of both good and evil and like to alternate. Write two half-length sections of a full length sequal. You can even tangle the two paths!

   47. 

       Creator Isobel on July 29, 2012

       Good.

   48. 

       Creator Nathan on July 29, 2012

       How could I decide without completing the first book?

   49. 

       Creator Kristina Sutton on July 29, 2012

       Good

   50. 

       Creator Banhai on July 29, 2012

       Good